As a long time Trekkie and having watched every show to date at least twice I have to say the show is cautiously promising.
After watching the first two episodes I see a glimmer of hope in the horizon mainly because of the fact that Brian Fuller's writing appeals to me. Knowing that he left mid-production worries me but at least we have a Trek series again.Even one such as that.
The Pros: - The plot. The first two episodes basically tell the story of the start of the war between the Klingon Empire and the Federation, which I personally think is an interesting and promising choice for a story line.
- The Effects. Although when I think Trek, special effects is the last thing on my mind, I enjoyed the 'modernised' and stylistic choices they went with with regard to the transporter effects, force fields etc.
-Some of the dialogue. Although the constant subtitling for the Klingons is going to get tiresome, I liked the dialogue between the Klingon leader and the high council and also when he died. The fed side dialogue felt weird and out of place in parts but I tried to keep an open mind since I can't help but compare it with the previous movies/shows.
The Cons: - Alex Kurtzman: A producer best known for utter rubbish like Spiderman 2 and Transformers and the show reeks with Kurtzman's 'vision' of Star Trek. If this show gets cancelled after this season it will be his doing believe me. Like the reboot films, the show went with his 'creative' approach to making the Klingons look like crap (at least they did away with the bling bling), phasers to blasters (yaaay star wars), ships to flying junkyards for the klingons, warping with no to stupid/cheap effects the list goes on. Like his buddy J.J. "The master plagiarist" Abrams he did more disservice to the franchise than Berman/Braga's space Nazis in Enterprise. Kurtzman and Abrams should be shot at dawn by a firing squad using their starwarsy pew pews for what they did to Trek.
-Michelle Yeoh. I was honored to learn that there will be a Captain called Georgiou (being Greek myself) and then... Michelle Yeoh. A captain of Asian descent with a Greek name is...fine. But why choose such an uninspiring, wooden actor to portray the Captain? I mean after William Shatner, Patrick Stewart, Avery Brooks and Kate Mulgrew you choose HER as the captain? I thought Bakula was a bad choice but now I am thinking Bakula deserved an Emmy compared to her. But then again the Captain is not the main character, is it? I hope Lorca is better....
-The Captain will probably not be the central character. A Trek show centered around....a disgraced, mutineer first officer stripped of rank and sentenced to life imprisonment. I know Jonathan Frakes will be smiling, but why?
I give this a 6 based solely on the plot so far. I hope as a Trekkie it gets better later on or this will surely be the death of Trek shows forever and we will be stuck with The Orville.
5 out of 16 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends