Change Your Image
johnasinb
Reviews
Poirot: Appointment with Death (2008)
Disturbingly Different
Poirot mentions Mrs. Boynton's sadistic tendencies. This adaptation felt the need to increase them and add physical cruelty to mental cruelty. It also repeated the sequence repeatedly. This alone turned a darker Christie story into an unpleasant viewing experience.
The adaptations toward the end of the series seem to move farther from the original stories. I will not watch this one again and will be selling my copy.
Poirot: Death on the Nile (2004)
It plays better 10 years later
I first bought this DVD when it came out. I thought so little of it at the time that I sold my copy. While the plot was fine, the British actress' American accents were not quite convincing. In the interim, I have been reading the Christie cannon in order from the publishing date and David Suchet has completed all of the possible Poirots. After reading a book, it is nice to compare it to the movie. The script writing stayed very close to Christie's work. Three of the characters got subsumed into others or dropped completely making it able to follow the characters presented in the show. What I did not like was the changing of the ending for two characters who ended up engaged in the book. It did not seem necessary.
The accents did not change in the subsequent years, but I deemed them better than some I have recently seen and am thus less of a snob.