tomintoul, having just seen "Immortal Beloved" for the first (and probably last) time, I was going to comment on it here. However, having read your comments, I must admit that I could not have said it better. I bought this film some time ago, but had never gotten around to playing it (now I don't wonder--). When I first approach any film, I usually just put it on to play when I am cleaning house or otherwise going about my business. Then, if I think it is worth it, I will sit down and give it all my attention. Music-wise, this film is wonderful, as how could it be otherwise? I fell in love with Beethoven when I was in grade school (not a few years ago!). I heard the "Ode to Joy" and I was hooked for life. To me, Beethoven was a man among men, and now a god among gods-- However, this piece of you-know-what is totally unworthy of him. When I realized where they were going in the naming of the "Immortal Beloved," I said to myself, "Oh--my--God! They wouldn't DARE!" However, they did dare, and this is what wrecks the film altogether. Get any of von Karajan's recordings. He was the total master of Beethoven's music, and whenever anyone wants to know about Beethoven, just listen to his music--
Review of Immortal Beloved
