"Chicago" and "Moulin Rouge" create a longing for more musicals of this quality. I'm old enough to remember when "Music Man", "West Side Story", "Seven Brides for Seven Brothers", "American in Paris" and so many more brought such life, joy and good old fashioned fun to the movies. For those of you who don't remember those days, I hope they're upon us again. I've heard some nits picked about Renee not being a really good singer, or Gere not a good dancer. These people miss the point. They're both excellent in their roles and that is the point!