Bad Sister (1931)
6/10
"I just know you're going to be happy."
10 October 2004
Warning: Spoilers
Let's see, Wade loves Marianne, Dick loves Marianne, Laura loves Dick, Marianne loves Val, Val loves himself. By film's end, Dick loves Laura, Marianne loves Wade and everyone lives happily ever after.

Despite the opening comments, "The Bad Sister" is not that hard to follow, even with it's soap opera feel. Bette Davis in her first film role displays some of her future star quality as Laura Madison, but here she's quite timid and demure, much unlike her many portrayals to come and definitely not the bad sister. That role is left for Sidney Fox, who as Marianne Madison displays all the manipulative, spiteful and bitchy behavior you just love to hate in a character. Marianne plays everyone for a fool, but sinks to an all time low when she forges her father's signature to a letter supporting a questionable business venture by the slick Val Corliss (Humphrey Bogart in his fourth film). Corliss skips town, leaving John Madison's partners as well as Marianne literally holding the bag.

Up to that point, the film offers a fairly respectable and tense drama, but literally implodes when the ailing father offers to take the rap and cover for Marianne. In a total reversal of character, Marianne admirably confesses, and the businessmen seem satisfied that her father will make good on their bad decision. But in an entirely too simple and unrealistic ending, the "reformed" Marianne is shown smooching with the bumbling Wade, while inviting all the rest of the happy family into the Madison home. It's a feel good ending that doesn't work for all that went before.
20 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed