Not bad, not great but not bad
28 November 2004
First of all, let me say how surprised I was to find out that Jason Alexander could sing so well. As the rest of the world probably knows, he did win a Tony award for Best Performance as a Leading Actor in Jerome Robbin's 'Broadway'. Had I known this, I would have lobbied for a musical Seinfeld!

But I digress. Kelsey Grammar did a wonderful job as Scrooge. Very mean, very nasty, very unlikeable. No surprises there - Grammar is a great actor.

My problem with the show was ... well, it just didn't have the best writing. Making a musical like this takes away from the time needed for character development and so they relied on the viewer having already seen twelve renditions of A Christmas Carol. But on its own, there were way too many holes in the story.

Anyway, I did enjoy it, but I wouldn't buy the video. Seeing it on TV once was enough.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed