Benny has everything! A wealthy family that gives him a great life, money to spend with his friends at McDonalds, more money so that he can rent the videos he wants at the videostore; everything constitutes for Benny being a good teenager, or a good person. But he also has a darker side: a strange fascination for death that seems to increase in his soul, to later be exteriorized in his body, after filming a horrific execution of a pig (showed right in the opening and repeated one more time). That image leads to his first real crime, the murder of a young girl randomly picked on the street, who is brutally murdered by him. Reason: Out of curiosity.
In "Benny's Video" director Michael Haneke argues about our hunger for violence, a hunger that seem to be everywhere, it follows us all the time and we can't deny our impression with it (that's why violent films are more popular than artistic films). It's present in the films Benny rents, on the news he watches with his parents, everywhere. Who can blame the boy? His morbid desire had to be fulfilled, he needed to know if killing someone is a unimpressive experience than the one he has while watching his films or repeatedly watching the pig's death, first in the usual speed, than in slow motion. Here's a boy who recurred to violence simply because no one was around (mother and father were traveling) and nothing could stop him at the moment. And we could say that he could go on killing more people given the fact his parents haven't turned him to the police but he saw that what he did was too much.
Played by an always impressive Arno Frisch (way before of making of us his accomplices with his disturbing and violent experiences in "Funny Games"), Benny is quite a figure and his deadly obsessions and the murder makes Macaulay Culkin's pranks in "The Good Son" something funny. In all of his amazing stoicism, the killing of a girl was acceptable but seeing what his parents did, covering up for him and getting rid of the corpse was way worst and that he couldn't tolerate (that explains the ending, in part). And the parents (played by Ulrich Mühe, ironically he would play the victim of Frisch in "Funny Games" and Angela Winkler) are even hard to imagine, not in the sense of they saying they love their son (when they don't) but this protection and their cold reaction on the fact he murdered someone (the mother even burst in laughter right after Benny's confession). Not a single emotion appears right after that, except when they travel to Egypt (while the father arranges a way to disappear with the girl's body) the mother shows some reaction by crying but even that crying seems so doubtful, we can't know for sure why she's doing that.
Haneke impresses us by showing how Benny committed the crime but without appealing to the Hollywood formula of gore, yet it is a disturbing moment. He puts a camera filming a part of the house, we can only hear what's happening in the other room, the girl screams, the sound of the gun (a captive bolt pistol, same thing used by Anton Chigurh in a more well known film) being used. It's difficult to not be shocked or feel frozen after that. More impressive than this moment only the first (and real) image of the film, already mentioned, something quite unnecessary on a film that wants to make a criticism over violence but opens this same film to the shock of many viewers. How many continued to watch after the pig's execution? If you can't deal with it, just fast forward these 40 seconds, and continue to watch the film, the discussions made by "Benny's Video" are many, all of them welcome and relevant.
I have some issues with the film in terms of its structure but I can't understand all this complain about the film being slow. It's slow paced but it's not that bad. The way Haneke used slowness at some points and in some of the three acts that was unnerving. The first act deals with the controversial and most interesting part of the film, the one in which we keep asking ourselves 'what comes next?'. The trip to Egypt was boring, it often breaks the pace of the movie, and when it's not doing this it gets worse when it seems to take us out of the movie, it seems a different film with nowhere to go and nothing to say. But when we reach the third act, back in Sweden, it comes some good surprises; then, finally leaves us with some doubts about the ending.
Brutal in its reality, shocking in its content but subtle in its presentation, this is an uncomfortable and unsettling film that doesn't exist to inspire more Benny's out there, in case some detractors might think that films like this are responsible for violence in the world. It's there to open our eyes to a wider, depressive and sad reality that could be happening close to you and you wouldn't know. 9/10
In "Benny's Video" director Michael Haneke argues about our hunger for violence, a hunger that seem to be everywhere, it follows us all the time and we can't deny our impression with it (that's why violent films are more popular than artistic films). It's present in the films Benny rents, on the news he watches with his parents, everywhere. Who can blame the boy? His morbid desire had to be fulfilled, he needed to know if killing someone is a unimpressive experience than the one he has while watching his films or repeatedly watching the pig's death, first in the usual speed, than in slow motion. Here's a boy who recurred to violence simply because no one was around (mother and father were traveling) and nothing could stop him at the moment. And we could say that he could go on killing more people given the fact his parents haven't turned him to the police but he saw that what he did was too much.
Played by an always impressive Arno Frisch (way before of making of us his accomplices with his disturbing and violent experiences in "Funny Games"), Benny is quite a figure and his deadly obsessions and the murder makes Macaulay Culkin's pranks in "The Good Son" something funny. In all of his amazing stoicism, the killing of a girl was acceptable but seeing what his parents did, covering up for him and getting rid of the corpse was way worst and that he couldn't tolerate (that explains the ending, in part). And the parents (played by Ulrich Mühe, ironically he would play the victim of Frisch in "Funny Games" and Angela Winkler) are even hard to imagine, not in the sense of they saying they love their son (when they don't) but this protection and their cold reaction on the fact he murdered someone (the mother even burst in laughter right after Benny's confession). Not a single emotion appears right after that, except when they travel to Egypt (while the father arranges a way to disappear with the girl's body) the mother shows some reaction by crying but even that crying seems so doubtful, we can't know for sure why she's doing that.
Haneke impresses us by showing how Benny committed the crime but without appealing to the Hollywood formula of gore, yet it is a disturbing moment. He puts a camera filming a part of the house, we can only hear what's happening in the other room, the girl screams, the sound of the gun (a captive bolt pistol, same thing used by Anton Chigurh in a more well known film) being used. It's difficult to not be shocked or feel frozen after that. More impressive than this moment only the first (and real) image of the film, already mentioned, something quite unnecessary on a film that wants to make a criticism over violence but opens this same film to the shock of many viewers. How many continued to watch after the pig's execution? If you can't deal with it, just fast forward these 40 seconds, and continue to watch the film, the discussions made by "Benny's Video" are many, all of them welcome and relevant.
I have some issues with the film in terms of its structure but I can't understand all this complain about the film being slow. It's slow paced but it's not that bad. The way Haneke used slowness at some points and in some of the three acts that was unnerving. The first act deals with the controversial and most interesting part of the film, the one in which we keep asking ourselves 'what comes next?'. The trip to Egypt was boring, it often breaks the pace of the movie, and when it's not doing this it gets worse when it seems to take us out of the movie, it seems a different film with nowhere to go and nothing to say. But when we reach the third act, back in Sweden, it comes some good surprises; then, finally leaves us with some doubts about the ending.
Brutal in its reality, shocking in its content but subtle in its presentation, this is an uncomfortable and unsettling film that doesn't exist to inspire more Benny's out there, in case some detractors might think that films like this are responsible for violence in the world. It's there to open our eyes to a wider, depressive and sad reality that could be happening close to you and you wouldn't know. 9/10