8/10
History but only as Hollywood tells it.
5 November 2012
Warning: Spoilers
On one level this is quite an entertaining western in glorious Technicolor and Cinemascope with good action sequences directed in a no nonsense fashion by Edward Bernds who works in the confines of a limited budget.

Steve Cochran plays a rather colorless hero (one wonders whether Rory Calhoun turned the part down) but where the film benefits is in the presence of Leo Gordon,one of the great western villains.In this film he plays William Quantrill as a thoroughly nasty piece of work without any redeeming features whatsoever.

Don Siegal, who directed Gordon in "Riot in cell block 11" was quoted as saying that Leo Gordon was the scariest man he ever met.Incidentally that film was made at San Quentin where Gordon had been imprisoned for three years for armed robbery.It says a lot for his character that he completely reformed and became a successful actor and screen writer,he was also happily married for fifty years.

The plot supposedly tells the story of Quantrill's raid on Lawrence,Kansas in August 1863.It trashes history to such an extent that one cannot take it seriously and as for the firearms used we are talking 1880's rather than 1860's.If one wants to see an accurate film based on the Civil War in Missouri I would recommend Ang Lee's "Ride with the Devil".

William Quantrill has always been seen by Hollywood as a cold blooded killer whether played by the likes of Walter Pidgeon,John Ireland or Brian Donlevy.Leo Gordon's version is even nastier.Types like Billy the Kid and Jesse James have on occasion had their characters whitewashed.As another reviewer has suggested perhaps its time to re-evaluate Quantrill

Quantrill was indeed a colourfull character,a violent man who lived in violent times.In his defense he held a genuine Captains commission in the Confederate Army and he did try to maintain a modicum of discipline even hanging two of his followers for raping and murdering women.In that respect he had a certain decency.He was eventually replaced by the likes of Bloody Bill Anderson and Archie Clements.Members of his gang included the James and Younger brothers.

On the other side of the coin Jennison's Jayhawkers and James Lanes Redlegs who supposedly fought for the Union committed just as many atrocities.As the James Lane character says in "The Outlaw Josey Wales" to the victor the spoils.

Enjoy the film on its own level,Leo Gordon is always worth watching.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed