Earthlings (2005)
3/10
How the hell did this get such a high rating?
1 February 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Man oh man. I can only believe that this is a move that appeals heavily to those already converted to veganism or something?

Yes, some of the scenes were barbaric and I firmly believe in honesty about where our food comes from and where it is manufactured.

I didn't feel this was an honest film however. It doesn't show the "standard practices" - some of what it shows is, and what really happens in abattoirs is gruesome - and hell, I'm glad I'm not a cow - but this smacks of propaganda rather than a documentary. There is no evenness to it.

And additionally - there is no interest in it. I had to fast forward the first section as it was incredibly long and tedious. Phoenix's voice is (pretty sure intentionally) inflectionless. Monotonous.

I had no problem with the subject matter - but as a film, it's just bad.

Something like Food Inc gets its point across much better - and the movie has a narrative, a story, something to draw you in.

This movie just preaches to the converted.

Bleh.
26 out of 76 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed