...It would not have looked like it did in this episode.
First off, Deep Space Nine was the best of the 90's Trek Spin-offs- And the only one to do The Original Series homage with the great "Trials and Tribbleations" episode from Season 5. Another thing I have to refute right away is the concept that science and religion are somehow at odds and that a civilization with Spaceflight would discard Faith: Not Religion per say, but Faith. If I do not have any problems in my mind with my own Faith in regards to theories like Evolution and The Big Bang which I also believe in as much as I believe in God or Jesus, then there will be more people like me who will start agreeing that if God exists, He does not break His own laws of Physics and He does not Snap His fingers or Play with Dice when He creates something, instead He would plan it out scientifically and He would follow the Laws of the Universe He had laid out. It is a new Mindset that has to be reached by both people who are religious, and scientists as well- There has to be an eventual meeting of the two or else there will never really be any huge breakthroughs, especially in a possible future that is anything like Gene Roddenberry's vision of The Federation.
The problem with stories like this and not just this story, but the idea that Rome was somehow "Evil" and Barbaric, is due to mostly Catholic Teaching, the same Catholic Teaching I was raised into. But this teaching it is false as I will explain here.
Think about it - What happened when the Goths - Not the same Goths that hang out in Nightclubs and listen to the bands "Bauhaus" and "Specimen," but real Barbarians who were great at fighting but terrible with Administration- Knocked down Rome and tried to Administrate it? What actually did happen was that they failed and they themselves entered Oblivion, and we ended up with several centuries of The Dark Ages which was the result of Religion but no Science. The same could happen if there were an era of Science but no Faith.
And so this Trek episode shows a Parallel Earth which had developed along the lines of our earth, but that Rome had not been knocked down. What was not considered in this story is that if Rome had continued in the direction it was going, it would have become a Catholic State, rather than a Pagan state, because it's final leaders were religious.
But let's say that Jesus came even to That earth, which He must have done there, as well as here, and at the same time He appeared Here. He never called for any bloody revolutions, His aim was Peace. He never backed up anybody who was fighting the government of that time, which was Rome, and he actually had harsher words for Hypocritical Priests of His own religion than He had for the Governors of Jerusalem or other Romans.
The Roman State from this episode, does not take into account that even The United States was just as barbaric, but social developments would have happened there as well, a state like Rome would have eventually developed socially to be more like the United States, and slavery and Gladiators would have been abolished.
So, this episode has many flaws, mostly due to the thinking of the time and also what was allowed on Television in 1967 and 1968. Despite that, I hold this episode as special to myself, because of my own personal Faith, and this was the only time in The Original Series where my Faith was saluted. In the 60's, you could not use blatant references to religion like you can with modern television, and possibly the word "Jesus" was a network taboo. So Gene Roddenberry went behind the backs of all of those taboos and brought us this episode, it really is one of the best of Season 2, and mostly it is less about Faith than about breaking The Prime Directive for any reason. And so I blame "The Fall of The Roman Empire" in this episode on Captain Merrick (William Smithers) and his blatant defiling of The Prime Directive - Not on Slaves staging a religious revolt. This episode shows the ultimate tragedy of not adhering to Starfleet's number one rule - a Whole world government was taken down and a bloody revolution was begun resulting in a possible Dark Ages for that planet.
But there was one shining moment in this episode and that was when "Mericus" finally came to his senses: he knew what would happen and he did it anyway, which showed a level of bravery.
This episode got away with social commentary because they didn't blatantly name religious figures or religions. "Son" worshipers, and we assumed "Sun", how wrong were we?
I originally saw this on the date that it was first broadcast, and being raised in a Catholic family it definitely caused a reaction around the TV set that night.
First off, Deep Space Nine was the best of the 90's Trek Spin-offs- And the only one to do The Original Series homage with the great "Trials and Tribbleations" episode from Season 5. Another thing I have to refute right away is the concept that science and religion are somehow at odds and that a civilization with Spaceflight would discard Faith: Not Religion per say, but Faith. If I do not have any problems in my mind with my own Faith in regards to theories like Evolution and The Big Bang which I also believe in as much as I believe in God or Jesus, then there will be more people like me who will start agreeing that if God exists, He does not break His own laws of Physics and He does not Snap His fingers or Play with Dice when He creates something, instead He would plan it out scientifically and He would follow the Laws of the Universe He had laid out. It is a new Mindset that has to be reached by both people who are religious, and scientists as well- There has to be an eventual meeting of the two or else there will never really be any huge breakthroughs, especially in a possible future that is anything like Gene Roddenberry's vision of The Federation.
The problem with stories like this and not just this story, but the idea that Rome was somehow "Evil" and Barbaric, is due to mostly Catholic Teaching, the same Catholic Teaching I was raised into. But this teaching it is false as I will explain here.
Think about it - What happened when the Goths - Not the same Goths that hang out in Nightclubs and listen to the bands "Bauhaus" and "Specimen," but real Barbarians who were great at fighting but terrible with Administration- Knocked down Rome and tried to Administrate it? What actually did happen was that they failed and they themselves entered Oblivion, and we ended up with several centuries of The Dark Ages which was the result of Religion but no Science. The same could happen if there were an era of Science but no Faith.
And so this Trek episode shows a Parallel Earth which had developed along the lines of our earth, but that Rome had not been knocked down. What was not considered in this story is that if Rome had continued in the direction it was going, it would have become a Catholic State, rather than a Pagan state, because it's final leaders were religious.
But let's say that Jesus came even to That earth, which He must have done there, as well as here, and at the same time He appeared Here. He never called for any bloody revolutions, His aim was Peace. He never backed up anybody who was fighting the government of that time, which was Rome, and he actually had harsher words for Hypocritical Priests of His own religion than He had for the Governors of Jerusalem or other Romans.
The Roman State from this episode, does not take into account that even The United States was just as barbaric, but social developments would have happened there as well, a state like Rome would have eventually developed socially to be more like the United States, and slavery and Gladiators would have been abolished.
So, this episode has many flaws, mostly due to the thinking of the time and also what was allowed on Television in 1967 and 1968. Despite that, I hold this episode as special to myself, because of my own personal Faith, and this was the only time in The Original Series where my Faith was saluted. In the 60's, you could not use blatant references to religion like you can with modern television, and possibly the word "Jesus" was a network taboo. So Gene Roddenberry went behind the backs of all of those taboos and brought us this episode, it really is one of the best of Season 2, and mostly it is less about Faith than about breaking The Prime Directive for any reason. And so I blame "The Fall of The Roman Empire" in this episode on Captain Merrick (William Smithers) and his blatant defiling of The Prime Directive - Not on Slaves staging a religious revolt. This episode shows the ultimate tragedy of not adhering to Starfleet's number one rule - a Whole world government was taken down and a bloody revolution was begun resulting in a possible Dark Ages for that planet.
But there was one shining moment in this episode and that was when "Mericus" finally came to his senses: he knew what would happen and he did it anyway, which showed a level of bravery.
This episode got away with social commentary because they didn't blatantly name religious figures or religions. "Son" worshipers, and we assumed "Sun", how wrong were we?
I originally saw this on the date that it was first broadcast, and being raised in a Catholic family it definitely caused a reaction around the TV set that night.