What's the point of remaking the American version of a UK show ? We already had Top Gear USA on another channel, and after a couple of barely OK seasons, the show found its rhythm, and was a great alternative to Top Gear UK. It was different : it was only about the road trip or the challenge. No more guest, no more car reviews. It suited the American audience, with a shorter format. And the hosts were funny and interesting, they had a nice dynamic. So why not rehire those guys ? They went for 3 new guys, which aren't very funny, and have to start again with the guests and the reviews and all of that, which didn't work out in the first place with Top Gear USA seasons 1 and 2... And worst of all, they start with VW Beetles... So don't waste your time, wait until season 2 or 3, once they find a better format, or better hosts. But more likely the ratings will be terrible and the show will be canceled...
Review of Top Gear America
