An user pointed out that some imdb reviews (particularly the early one) were very negative ;but in spite of a huge success,many leftish (Marxist ?) comments were scathing too when the movie was released :remember that Spain was a dictatorship and a French critic went as far as to write that 'if Christ allows the mother-and -child reunion ,it's in a better world ,and thus it solves the problem of the orphanages maintenance".
Today ,when compared to the Joselito Jimenez weepies,which have sunk into oblivion, "Marcelino pan y vino " holds up quite well .That a great director such Luigi COMENCINI made a remake is proof positive that the movie has worn well ,even though today's children may not get something out of it.
Everyone will agree that Pablito Calvo gives one of the best child actor performances of all time ;one can,however ,prefer to the scenes in the attic :
-the bread which diminishes ,much to the monk /cook's surprise .
-the fair ,where the stolen apple creates a "butterfly effect" in miniature .
-the boy learning his alphabet,under a monk's watchful eye.
-the meeting with the woman with a madonna face(wish she could be my mama).
-the hidden treasures in the wall.
Today ,when compared to the Joselito Jimenez weepies,which have sunk into oblivion, "Marcelino pan y vino " holds up quite well .That a great director such Luigi COMENCINI made a remake is proof positive that the movie has worn well ,even though today's children may not get something out of it.
Everyone will agree that Pablito Calvo gives one of the best child actor performances of all time ;one can,however ,prefer to the scenes in the attic :
-the bread which diminishes ,much to the monk /cook's surprise .
-the fair ,where the stolen apple creates a "butterfly effect" in miniature .
-the boy learning his alphabet,under a monk's watchful eye.
-the meeting with the woman with a madonna face(wish she could be my mama).
-the hidden treasures in the wall.