The Sopranos: Whoever Did This (2002)
Season 4, Episode 9
10/10
If you can quote the rules, you can obey them
8 September 2022
Ralph goes through a tragedy and Tony is there to pick up the pieces.

This is an incredibly well made episode with a number of unforgettable moments.

There is no way of discussing plot details without spoiling, but it's safe to say that it is eventful, with characters like Tony, Ralph, and Christopher at the centre.

When you consider how many shifts in tone there are from one act to the next, it can be considered a quintessential Sopranos episode that has a bit of everything. There are great moments of dark comedy, tragic drama, angry/violent confrontation and quiet reflection.

There is a certain event, key to the plot, that happens off camera and as an audience we are left with degree of uncertainty about who is responsible. It does not matter to certain characters whether truth is revealed and the writers never allow us the pleasure. This type of uncertainty underpins a lot of drama in the Sopranos and it is a strength associated with this particular detail.

I love how it links back to the season 3 episode 'University' with a number of visual moments and it ties strongly into one of the bleakest show themes of the emptiness of existence.

Joe Pantoliano gives the standout performance of the episode and his best of the series. James Gandolfini and Michael Imperioli are excellent as always.

Visually it tells the story with wonderful cinematography, editing, and effects that are very impactful.
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed