Jim is joined by Carol Burnett and Ronnie Schell in a Lone Ranger spoof. Carol and Jim do a medley of songs about unrequited love. Frank Sutton discusses boxing. Jim sings "Down in the Valley."
Guest Kate Smith solos on "If He Walked into My Life" and "Fallin' in Love." She joins the rest of the cast in "Spirit of 1776." Host Jim Nabors croons "A Man Without Love" and "America."
Ricky Nelson performs "We've Got A Long Way To Go." Bobbi Gentry serenades the tune "Benjamin." Nelson and Nabors compete for the charms of a charming belle who is eager for a boyfriend.
Guest Glen Campbell sings "My Way" then duets with host Nabors on "Tennessee Birdwalk." They do a comedic bit about the French Foreign Legion. The entire company does a big production number entitled Riverboat Gambler.
Jim and Totie are two toddlers who are eagerly awaiting Santa as portrayed by Frank Sutton. Then Ronnie Schell is a major newscaster who interviews Brigitte Boffo, a French sexpot played by guest Totie.
Jane Wyman gives a dramatic reading of New Year's Gift. A vignette about a clumsy waiter serving at a high society function is played for laughs. Mary Costa sings a medley from the Broadwsy hit Carousel.
Jim is Prince Charming, Barbara McNair is Cindy with Sutton and Schell as the stepsisters in a spoof of Cinderella. Nabors sings "Personality." Miss McNair covers "Everything Is Beautiful."
Guest Shirley Jones entertains with a medley from Brigadoon. Then she joins host Jim Nabors in a duet of "Rose Garden." Shirley and Jim pose as honeymooners while doing hotel inspections in a comedy routine.