Happy Times (2000) Poster

(2000)

User Reviews

Review this title
41 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The Masseuse
jotix1005 September 2005
Yimau Zhang takes us along for a ride to explore how things seem to have changed in China. The country has given a step forward into the modern age as it shakes off its rigid past, adopting new ways in doing things. In fact, the country appears to have developed its own take on capitalism, as we watch a new prosperous, and aggressive China, transformed in ways we had not envisioned before. Mr. Zhang's film is an allegory about his country.

The main idea in the film is how Zhao, a factory worker, sets his eyes on a plump and attractive woman to get married. The woman, in turn, has her own ideas of what to expect from this man who lies to her and makes himself pass for a hotel manager. Thinking this is the case, the lady friend proposes he employs her stepdaughter, a blind girl that has been abandoned by her father, who has decamped to another city.

Zhao, who wants to keep the girlfriend happy, decides to take Wu Ying to work at his hotel, which in reality is a bus, that he and his buddy have converted in a lovers' motel, in a park. But before he can do anything, Zhao watches in horror as how some cleaning crews are taking his livelihood away because they are beautifying the area. Zhao is stuck with Wu Ying, so he takes her to his own humble apartment.

Zhao and his friends from the factory devise a plan to convert space in the dilapidated building a massage parlor so that the blind girl can work. The only thing, there are no clients, and only Zhao's friends are enrolled to tip the young woman using Zhao's own money.

The film is a delightful comedy about how being entrepreneurial backfires on the well intentioned man. The blind girl, Wu Ying, knows much more than what Zhao and the rest give her credit for, and unfortunately, everything ends badly, except for the blind girl, who recognizes the kindness of his mentor, who doesn't get to know first hand of her gratitude because fate intervenes.

"Happy Times" is a charming film that works thanks to the light touch by the director. Benshan Zhao, who has been seen in other Chinese films is excellent in the role of Zhao. Jie Dong plays Wu Ying with conviction and Lifan Dong, is the stepmother, who discovers the duplicity of her would be husband.

Recommended to all Yimou Zhang's fans who might have missed its commercial run.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
One of Zhang Yimou's best!
jokercard8820 December 2002
This film will either get to you like a death in the family, or leave no lasting impression on you whatsoever. I'm among those who fit in with the first part. Maybe family death is exaggerating but that doesn't matter, this is still A VERY POWERFUL FILM. This film proves that ZHANG YIMOU IS THE BEST DIRECTOR ALIVE (as Alferd Hitchcock and Akira Kurosawa are dead). The best actor in this film is actually the blind girl (sure, she's no River Pheonix, but who is?) who always gives you the impression that she's blind (unlike some American actors in American films). Yet she happens to know more than you think in the end (no spoilers on that). To see this film on the big screen was too much, 10 out of 10. Oh, and watch out for Hero, from the same director of this.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Contemporary Zhang
EdgarST30 January 2004
I am not too impressed with Zhang Yimou's sentimentality in his films with a contemporary milieu –which I've been watching lately- but I prefer these to a couple of ornate reworkings he made (two or three in a row, if I am not mistaken) about Chinese woman's social conditions in the past, as a reflection on today's improvement or lack of it. "Red Sorghum" is still a favorite of mine, but I had to wait for "To Live" to see a different angle of his moviemaking. Though livelier in spirit than those period dramas, this one is based on a literary source and it shows, the more so if compared to the similar but free story of the young teacher in "Not One Less". Zhang concentrates on an old man wanting a wife, but his better characters are still the women: the blind girl –with the open resolution of her character- is more complex than the old man and one wonders what she will do next; while her stereotypical stepmother and the only female retired friend of the old man are quite attractive and would also make good stories. A fine movie just the same.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Excellent dramatic fable!
yossarian10025 February 2003
6 Stars! This is a must see movie but be warned....the description of this film is not what this film's about. It is not a comedy, even though parts of the story are actually funny. It is a fable about compassion and the amount of deception sometimes needed to achieve it, especially by the inept. Happy Times is directed by Yimou Zhang, who gave us the masterpiece The Road Home, and it is very moving and terribly sad and oddly funny. If you like being delighted and surprised, watch this one.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The true meaning of life
luisguillermoc327 April 2010
There is, in this world, many parents, siblings or grandparents are, but they always angry, especially when it comes to their loved ones. His "generosity" is full of contempt, anger and I think that self-frustration for failing to more fortunate children or grandchildren or more committed to themselves. This giving is worth very little, because the recipient feel humiliated, and love is hate and what does not grow in his heart, first by himself, by being forced to receive from whoever stain, and second, that which gives because he knows that, at bottom, despises him.

There is in this world, and fortunately, people who are eager to give and to serve because he feels playing the role for which he was born, then, when given the heart, there is nothing more rewarding for humans to feel that someone has released a fix or which has helped improve their quality of life. Being that really works, do not expect rewards, for the simple flow makes you feel full, and instead wanted to thank you, it is he who gives them for being in a state of abundance.The sincere and loving act of giving is an act of creation because it is spreading, confidence and hope.

It is this that comes Zhao, a man old enough and who, wishing to mate with a plump woman conflictive existence, just knowing Wu Ying, a sweet blind teenager who, motherless and abandoned by her father with his stepmother, he began to feel that, this woman is charging the resentment what she feels for his volatile father. Zhao, take time to under the beautiful Wu and begin a long quest to get her access to the happy times, while getting to make sense of their existence.

Yimou's film, soon to look at the classic Charles Chaplin "City Lights" but his personal touch and very oriental, manages the film with feel and certain charm, though - it must be said - without the immense magic and poetic warmth that has the now classic work of Charlot. However, at the end one feels that, with grace and wisdom, "Happy Times", has shown a path that gives meaning to existence, and so, well deserve our warmest applause.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The wrong things; the right reasons
Junker-27 February 2004
Zhao is a 50 year old unemployed loser making one last attempt at finding love. He courts a portly divorcee, but keeps having to lie to pass himself off as a better catch than he really is. Eventually, of course, the lies backfire. Zhao tells his sweetheart that he is the manager of a fancy hotel. She responds by foisting her blind stepdaughter off on him, confident that he can easily find her employment at his fancy hotel.

What follows is a funny, unlikely and touching relationship between Zhao and the blind girl Wu. While Zhao is terribly misguided, constructing elaborate deceptions to keep Wu "employed" at the non-existent hotel, he does these wrong things for the right reasons. Zhao does find love, but it isn't the woman or the love he expected.

This is an excellent film and there are three big reasons why: First of all, it's directed by Zhang Yimou who may well be the best director alive. This isn't a masterpiece like "Raise the Red Lantern," but seeing the phrase "Directed by Zhang Yimou" should be enough to tell you the next two hours will be well spent.

The second and third reasons are Benshan Zhao as Zhao and Jei Dong as Wu. Zhao is a respected Chinese comedian, but the role here is really a mixture of comedy and drama. Zhao gives the mixture exactly the right touch. But the real revelation is Jei Dong. I found myself wondering through the entire movie if she were really blind. She is that good. (And I still don't know the answer.)

Don't expect a laugh out loud comedy if you see this movie. It is very funny in places, but frequently that humor is very uncomfortable. And frequently happy times aren't really what they seem.
24 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Sometimes you just gotta go with it.
=G=8 December 2002
"Happy Times", a small time comedy out of China, tells of a less than successful middle-aged man who is desperately seeking a wife and finds a "daughter" instead. A lilting and sweetly sentimental comedy, this flick has a quirky kind of charm which defies description. I personally became completely bewitched by the film's simple, fresh, and unique style. But I suspect I'm the exception. "Happy Times" will most likely offer some happy time for sentimental viewers into neo-Chinese cinema exports. (B-)
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A beautiful little film
dsulpy8 December 2002
It seems that most of the negative reviews that this film has gotten are based upon people's misconception that the film should be what THEY want it to be, not what it really is. The truth is, although there's certainly humor in the film, it's not a comedy - nor does it pretend to be a fairy tale, or a social expose, or a political statement. To me, it's a film about cruelty and compassion - both by human beings and by fate. I found it both life-affirming, and heartbreaking - often at the same time, and I thought the acting was excellent on everyone's part. To me, well worth seeing, and quite unique.
24 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Sad And Heavy Movie That Leaves You With Nothing But Sympathy For The Main Characters
sddavis6328 August 2008
Warning: Spoilers
In order to really appreciate this film, you first have to get over what will probably be some shattered expectations. The movie is described as a "comedy-drama" and I've come across at least one commentator who described it as a "lighthearted" comedy. I'm not sure what movie that commentator was talking about, but "Happy Times" certainly isn't "lighthearted" nor did it come across to me as a comedy. There are some humorous moments in it (such as Li lying down on the massage table and having his head crash through the hole because it was too big) but for a good part of the movie I was feeling somewhat angry at what I was seeing, and, in the end, the overwhelming feeling I was left with was one of sadness. None of that is meant to say that this wasn't a good movie. It was. I was actually quite taken with it. It just wasn't what I was expecting at first and it took a while for me to reconcile my expectations with what I was actually seeing.

I said the movie left me with a feeling of sadness. That's largely because it was filled with sad characters. The movie revolves around Zhao, a lonely man who desperately wants to get married and who makes up a story about himself being a hotel owner to get a woman interested in him. The woman is a heavy-set twice divorced mom to a rather obnoxious son and the epitome of the wicked stepmother to 18 year old Wu - the blind daughter of one of the men who left her. She treats Wu like a servant and desperately wants to get rid of her, finally pawning her off on to Zhao, telling him to give her a job at his hotel. Zhao - carrying on the deceit - puts together a fake massage business (a legitimate one) and "hires" Wu to massage his friends, who finally end up having to pay her with fake money because they're all broke. Jie Dong was great as Wu, and Benshan Zhao equally good as Zhao.

My initial anger stemmed from the deceit that Wu was being surrounded by. That feeling changed to sadness when I realized that - aside from the stepmother - no one was being deliberately cruel to her. Zhao and friends really did seem to care for her, and Zhao develops an obviously affectionate, almost father-like relationship with her. Watching that relationship evolve was very interesting, but it all led up to - again - what I found a very sad ending, as Wu leaves to an unknown fate, and Zhao is abandoned by his girlfriend and then seriously hurt when he's hit by a truck and we're left not even knowing whether he'll survive. So, yes, it's sad and a bit heavy rather than lighthearted, but still quite well done with very good performances from the two leads that leave you with feelings of sympathy for both because in the end you really do like both Wu and Zhao. 7/10
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Small scale for Zhang Yimou, but still well made
devil.plaything27 April 2002
There is no doubt in my mind that Zhang Yimou is one of the world's finest film makers. He manages to straddle the bounds of both art house and commercialism with his catalogue of works that show a beauty and grandeur that often earns the description "painterly", whilst also telling a really good story. Happy Times is something of a departure from works like Raise The Lantern and Shanghai Triad, being a fairly realist comedy.

Happy Times ("Happy Times Hotel" on the print) is about a group of 'retired' (laid off) factory workers who conspire to hoax a young blind girl. Not as callous as it sounds though, as their intentions are relatively good. The main characters are a 50 year old bachelor (Zhao Benshan) and the blind girl herself, played by newcomer Dong Jie. A small crowd of interesting friends and the gargantuan love interest/stepmother of the leads pad out the cast, which mostly plays out in a couple of small locations - two cramped flats, a sprawling abandoned warehouse, and a delapidated bus.

It's very much a character piece, focussing mainly on the relationship that develops between Zhao Benshan and Dong Jie, thrust together under circumstances that neither planned. It's a tender story... a little bit happy, a little bit sad. Bittersweet I guess, but only slightly bitter.

Zhang Yimou forgoes his usual luscious cinematography for quite a naturalistic feel. Apparently he used "hidden cameras" to shoot some of it, but I've no idea what that means (maybe the street scenes?). It's quite a simple piece, a light 95 minutes long, yet still crafted with the dexterity and care that Zhang Yimou always brings to a film. Being a character piece, it is very much dependent on the performances for success - Zhang could coax an oscar winner out of a mannequin, but Dong Jie here is especially good. If I hadn't seen her walking around the theatre unattended, I would certainly have believed she was genuinely blind (this is not an easy thing to act), and her emotional expression is spot on too. You couldn't possibly not care for her character, or that of Zhao Benshan.

The movie might be quite 'slight' in Zhang Yimou's filmography - it's unlikely to win any oscars for him, but it is a nicely made movie that I think everybody can enjoy.
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
It was indeed happy times...
paul_haakonsen2 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Being a fan of Asian cinema, I decided to give this movie a go, so I purchased it from Amazon, and having just seen it, I can honestly say that I think something is missing from this movie. It is a great movie, but there is just something missing to make it that one notch more memorable. And I must admit that I had expected the movie to be more of a comedy than a drama about life.

**Warning! The following part here contains spoiler to the ending of the movie.**

Perhaps it was the semi-lousy ending to the movie. After all of Zhao's (played by Benshan Zhao) effort to give Wu Ying (played by Jie Dong) a purpose in life and make her life meaningful, he ends up in a hospital, and we don't get to know his fate? That was not very satisfactory to me. However, I will say that seeing Wu Ying on the street alone walking off at the end was just beautiful. It was nice to see that she was determined to make an effort and try on her own.

The story itself was nice, Zhao is courting a woman (played by Qibin Leng) and ends up having to take care of her blind girl. But with little means and nothing real to offer, Zhao is put to the test. A test of the heart, so to speak.

I found the acting in "Happy Times Hotel" to be quite good, and most memorable was Jie Dong. She portrayed the blind girl, Wu Ying, so nicely and so believable.

"Happy Times Hotel" is a great movie, a beautiful movie, just a shame that it started to fall apart towards the end. The movie could have been so much more if the director (Yimou Zhang) had opted to go a different direction. I felt that us viewers were left with so many unanswered questions to the story, and that was a shame, because it made the movie feel incomplete. But still, given the great story, then this movie is well worth checking out.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Simple story with social/political allegory
chmilar15 June 2004
Warning: Spoilers
The simple story of Happy Times overlays an interesting commentary on China's government, society, and future.

The first act of film creates the characters, their relationships, and the overall situation, to set up the political allegory that plays out in the final two acts. The story unfolds that retired/laid-off Old Zhao must take care of the young blind girl, Wu Ying. Through a series of lies, Zhao has put himself in a situation where, although he is retired and poor, Wu Ying believes he owns a successful hotel. He offers to give her a job in the hotel's massage room. (This is not a front for prostitution. In China, "blind man massage" is available in most cities.)

He uses the factory where he worked - which is shut down but not yet abandoned - and the help of his former workmates, to create a fake massage room and fake customers. Zhao also provides the money to pay Ying for massages, until the crew hits upon the idea of using fake money.

In the old China, the state guaranteed jobs for everyone. The patriarchal and authoritarian government wanted to show off their glorious communist system, and how well it worked (compared to the decadent capitalists, with their unemployment problems). The government could always print more money, to pay these workers.

The allegory is clear: Zhao represents the "state" - and its well-intentioned "make work" projects. The pride of Zhao (and his chances with his fiancee) is at stake, and he struggles to maintain the charade. As well, he finds that he cares for and is concerned about his charge, Ying.

In the end, two things happen independently: Zhao finds that he cannot sustain the masquerade - he is running out of money and resources (and gets into a situation where it is impossible for him to continue, and, indeed, might put Ying in desperate jeopardy); and Ying, who cottoned on to the charade long ago, decides to take responsibility for herself, and seek her own fortune.

In the same way, China's government realized it could not continue along its Maoist path, and its citizens (or at least some of them) were eager to be responsible for themselves, rather than relying on their government. A new path for China's people has opened, with greater responsibility and greater opportunity.

The film's ending brings mixed emotions: we are concerned for Ying, who must begin coping with the world with no help (at her own choice, although circumstances would force this choice, anyhow); at the same time, we are optimistic for her future possibilities; and we are sad that the relationship of Zhao and Ying has ended.

It is a tribute to director Zhang Yimou, Zhao Benshao (Zhao), and Dong Jie (Wu Ying) that the story and characters are touching, regardless of the underlying allegory. The movie plays well as the delicate and simple story of two people brought together by funny circumstances and human nature.
15 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Can't Zhang Yimou Make a Happy Film?????
zumajay12 April 2003
OK... this was supposed to be a comedy. NOPE!!! NADA!!! STAY AWAY IF YOU NEED A LAUGH. This movie was really rather sad and depressing... if there was any humor in it, it was beyond me. This movie angered me and depressed me at the same time...
5 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Excellent, must see, unique.
afarr00019 June 2005
This is one of the most touching films I've ever seen. I actually don't think I can find the words in English to describe how wonderfully director Zhang Yimou seems to understand the finer points of human emotions. I was absolutely touched with Happy Times, and consequently sought out his work, "The Road Home", which I found was equally excellent.

I wanted to wait to write a review of this film until I felt I could compose something fitting, but realized for me, the comments must come from the heart. In short, I'd rather skip any attempt to summarize the film or intellectually categorize it into some literal form that doesn't really fit. It is slowly immersing into unselfish love for another, while relating a sense of light comedy. My recommendation is that you try to see it on IFC or one of the other Independent film channels when it's available.

On Golden Pond is the only American film I can think of that evokes the same level of emotion provoked by Zhang Yimou.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
short and simple
SunnyBoi30 October 2003
About a retired factory worker who plans to marry an overweight, unattractive lady, only to wind up taking care of her unwanted, blind but beautiful daughter. Zhao Benshao's performance as the cheapskate, retired bachelor is outstanding, while newcomer Jie Dong (WuYing) plays the blind girl to perfection.

Another unhappy ending by Zhang Yimou, but don't let that faze you by this funny, touching and inspiring movie. Hard to find another movie like this one. 8 out of 10.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Touching, Well-Acted, Working Class Urban China with Haagen Daz
lawprof7 August 2002
No longer partnered, artistically or domestically, with the stunning Gong Li, director Zhang Yimou has probably redeemed himself with Party satraps through his engaging serio-comic "Happy Days." (He's been in and out of hot water with past films.) Destined to reach a miniscule audience in theaters, this touching film ought to be widely viewed when released for sale or rental.

Set in an unnamed Chinese city (definitely not Beijing), the story revolves around retired factory worker Zhau, just over fifty, and a blind teenager, Wu Ying, stepdaughter of the corpulent and avaricious woman the impecunious Zhau seeks as a wife. Wu Ying, blind since early childhood from a tumor, has to deal not only with her witch of a stepmom (dad fled from her and is supposedly in a far off city working to send money to bring his daughter to him) but with her stepbrother, a bulbous slobus amoebus training to match his mother's nastiness.

Zhau has a covey of good friends. His first get rich scheme, hatched up with his closest friend, is to "restore" a derelict bus in a park to its pristine state so it can be rented for quick, hot sheet assignations ("Happy Times Hotel"). Americans will find the Chinese take on non-marital, catch-as-catch-can sex naive but it reflects tension balanced by humor in a country where the citified young seek freedoms their elders never enjoyed.

The core of the story is Zhau's attempts to take care of Yu Wing after the evil stepmom throws her at Zhau and tells him to get her out of the house and keep her out. With his friends, all equally hovering near or under the poverty line, Zhau sets Yu Wing up as a masseuse in a fake massage parlor in a decrepit abandoned factory, the legitimate kind of parlor, not the type I heard about when an Army officer in severalAsian countries (Yu Wing was trained to give massages).

I won't reveal the lengths Zhau and his gang go to in their effort to sustain Yu Wing and make her happy. Some of their scheming is very funny. The ending reflects, hardly for the first time, Zhang Yimou's skill not only as a top director but also as a talented storyteller.

I've never seen the actor and actress who play the leads before. They simply blend their performances convincingly into a seamless story that says more about the possibilities and rewards of empathy and the joys of caring than it does about modern China. The locales here range from an affluent downtown to a condemned, empty factory. There's hardly any politics. It's sad, though, that a decent, retired factory worker can't spring for a 25 yuan Haagen Daz small cone offered in a shop that could have been imported from Main Street.

Put this one on your to-rent list!!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perfect.
flyingchimpanzee3 April 2002
Another winner from director Zhang Yimou. This scaled down production follows a blind, headstrong young woman and the one kind person in her life, (a penniless stranger with grand, idealistic schemes to improve her life). Charming and very funny with the usual outstanding performances. Highly recommended.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Masterpiece of Chinese Cinema
devilsmercy0324 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
I wish my films could capture the mellowness of Zhang's "Happy Times." The film follows a 50 year-old single man looking for love in all the wrong places. As old as that sound, "Happy Tims" makes it new again. Finally, he finds, what he thinks will be, his future wife. This very large woman as a son and a blind girl left with her, from her former boyfriend's former relationship. The girls father fled away looking for money. The woman wants the girl out of her home, so the bachelor takes her in as a worker in his fake massage parlor. This sounds horrible, taking advantage of a blind girl, but you realize it's mostly for good reason.

The cinematography is excellent. From the beautiful country-side to the big city, Zhang knows a thing or two about cinematography. If feels like a classic Asian film. I think most people will enjoy this more than "Hero" or "House of Flying Daggers." It has this mellowness and freedom that other films don't capture. You feel the connections between the characters, and the Ending will rock your world.

I only docked it because it's not for everyone. It's an artsy film. It's not Hero. It's not House of Flying Daggers. No fights. No swordplay. Just a raw bittersweet heart-warmer (NO! not a chick Flick!)
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Creepy and Bizarre
rkarpel17 August 2002
This is a comedy that tries to draws laughs from a scenario in which a group of nitwit retirees construct an elaborate fiction in order to deceive a blind woman. (The retirees, who are dropped into the plot without introduction about halfway through the film, are played by severely limited actors. ) Maybe the only movie I've ever seen that can be described as both cloyingly sentimental and unconscionably cruel.
6 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bittersweet
twob_ornot31 March 2002
This one's up to Zhang Yimou's usual standard, and like his other movies, revolves around an unfortunate female, in this case a young blind woman. Set in modern urban China, this movie often has a lighter touch than most of his others. Although the movie credits cite a story by Mo Yan, "Shifu, You'll do Anything for a Laugh" as the basis of the movie, the connection is highly tenuous, borrowing little more than the main character from that short story; namely, a middle-aged, laid-off factory worker, played by Zhao Benshan (best known to Chinese audiences as a comedic actor). The economic changes in modern China form the background to his relationship with the blind girl he finds himself thrown together with as he tries to court her step-mother.

I'd like to see someone pick this one up for distribution and given a better English title.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great Movie
herb200022 November 2003
Being brief, I found this to be a wonderful movie and story line. It is subtle throughout and has a simple but uplifting story. Some parts are funny, some just walk through the story and some are touching. It does have an unexpected ending that at first blush may appear to not be very positive but it is truly enriching.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A great movie with a real good story...
dbaskaya7 July 2005
It is a great movie... Yimou Zhang is one of the greatest directors on earth but one of the most overlooked talents. The world doesn't stop at Hollywood. Many great talents become overshadowed by the high budget Hollywood movies(and most of these movies literally don't tell "anything" to their audience). This is a movie with a stand, it presents a world-view and most importantly it is humane... It has a story with sub-texts and in these sub-texts, most people may find many details familiar to their emotional experiences. It is an intimate movie because it tells about "the good side of the mankind that we all must preserve in ourselves". I recommend it to everyone.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wonderful Gem of a Film
GlennInWinnipeg13 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this in the middle of the night on CBC; and bought the DVD so that I could see the first part.

The acting is just amazing. It is a "different" comedy; but I would call it more a drama that has a lighter way of making a deep point; so that you do not realize how important the relationships will be. The purpose, I suppose is to give you more of an emotional impact because you just do not expect something so profound to happen.

The movie is surprisingly magnetic .. particularly when "little Wu" is introduced and you can see the interplay as all the relationships develop. Also the acting is so brilliant, that you somehow understand way more then they present - so you can tell the history of the characters just by the way the actors bring out 3-dimentional characters.

*Spoiler*** The ending, I really was not happy about - but the more I think about it, the more I am content with it. The original ending sounds better -- to me; if only to have the two main characters on the screen at the end. It is actually quite a shock as you really feel these two can heal each other.

Anyway, I HIGHLY recommend it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Forsaken, Brave China
RARubin7 April 2005
There's a whole lot more here than meets the eye. You don't have to be a friendless blind girl in a city of ten million to appreciate human frailty and kindness. Yimou Zhang is a very fine director and his vision can be thoughtful and appreciated on several levels. China is still exotic to look at from my American standpoint. The colors are garish and bright. The modern city bustles, the young are hip and making it where they can. The old worker's, many victims of the poverty and cruelty caused by The Great Leap Forward and other catastrophic Marxist disasters, are still searching for happiness. Now, in their fifties, they look about and their old factories are rusting, glass office towers are going sky high.

I'm still not sure that the actress that played a blind teen is not actually blind. Either way, she's a genius. Her final scene, forsaken, blind, but brave China, venturing into the traffic. This is film-making.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
"Happy Times" does not have a happy ending
sdblosom20 May 2006
Warning: Spoilers
We watch two lonely people meet and struggle and in the end, the worst possible events occur and I felt like I watched what felt like 3 hours for naught.

Two sad, lonely people meet by chance, try to make each other happy but do the wrong things for all of the right reasons. In the end, they part out of misunderstanding and the audience is left at a cliffhanger not knowing what will happen next.

Now I feel depressed.

I don't know about you, but if I watch 3 hours of people struggling and then have it all end with a simple misunderstanding, it makes me angry and I feel as thought I wasted my time. Don't watch if you like happy endings! This is not a "happy" movie at all!
3 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed