"Mannix" The Crimson Halo (TV Episode 1972) Poster

(TV Series)

(1972)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
The Return of "Lew Wickersham"
Aldanoli26 March 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Joseph Campanella, who co-starred in the series' first season, makes his one return appearance in this episode, more than four years after his last bow as "Lew Wickersham," Mannix' boss at the private detective firm "Intertect." As the head of Intertect, Wickersham/Campanella had a fondness for state-of-the-art electronic gizmos (well, 1967 vintage, anyway, like tracking devices), including a bank of closed-circuit televisions with which he could spy on his subordinates' offices, including -- especially -- Joe Mannix.

This could have provided an opportunity to have a trip down memory lane, re-visiting the wonders of Intertect's electronic wizardry, and once again contrasting it with lone wolf Joe Mannix' preference to eschew those devices in favor of his fists and his easy charm. It also would have given the series a sense of continuity by bringing back the one continuing character besides the rotating police officers played by folks like Larry Linville, Robert Reed, Jack Ging, or Ward Wood.

But it was not to be. Unfortunately, Campanella is instead cast here in the role of an arrogant, trail-blazing surgeon named Graham Aspinall, who apparently survives an attempt on his life by a prowler, prompting his attorney to ask Joe Mannix to find out why anyone would want the good doctor dead.

Sadly, the story is also riven with lots of plot points that don't hold up well under even cursory examination, and Campanella has some odd encounters with Joe Mannix -- beginning with a confrontation at his tennis club where Mannix, dressed in his usual sport coat and tie, follows Aspinall into the locker room -- and even tries to interrogate him while he's taking a shower! You couldn't wait outside until the poor guy had a chance to get showered and dressed, Joe?

Equally odd are the conversations Mannix has with two of the women in Dr. Aspinall's life -- one with his research assistant played by Laraine Stephens, who trades barbs with Mannix while garbed in a slinky orange dress and then disappears from the episode for good; and one with Irish actress Fionnuala Flanagan as Aspinall's secretary, who offers to let Mannix look at the doctor's patient records apparently because the script calls for it. Weren't medical records confidential back in the 1970s?

Still, if the episode has a redeeming feature (apart from seeing Connors and Campanella together one last time, even in such a disappointing episode), it's that old warhorse Burgess Meredith playing Aspinall's lawyer, who summons Mannix to his office -- which is large enough to play basketball in -- where Mannix finds the leprechaun-sized Meredith hunched over his desk wearing a gold vest. On anyone else the outfit would look pretentious, but Meredith carries it off. Sadly, he's only in the episode for three or four brief (though important) scenes, but his scenery-chewing is reason enough to see this episode, even if Campanella weren't in it.
16 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Good, but they made the people in this one just too difficult to be realistic.
planktonrules16 March 2015
This is an interesting episode because Joseph Campanella guest stars. And why is this so particularly interesting? Well, during the first season of "Mannix", he worked for a detective agency and Campanella played his boss! Here, however, he plays an entirely different person--Dr. Aspinall.

Following an attempt on Dr. Aspinall's life, his attorney, Mr. Ortway (Burgess Meredith) contacts Mannix and offers him the case. Ortway, however, is a bit cagey and annoying and it's a wonder Mannix took the case. What's a bigger mystery, however, is why he stayed on the case. After all, Aspinall was a horse's butt--and was about as pleasant as a brain tumor!! He refused Mannix's help and was a jerk. Now this might have made some attempt at first, but when there's a second attempt on Aspinall's life and he really didn't know who was doing it and why, it simply made no sense at all why he worked so hard to get Mannix off the case. I would sure welcome the help if someone was trying to kill me!! What follows is a good episode with an interesting motive but it's hindered because too many people are like Aspinall's character--they behave in ways that don't make a lot of sense. As a result, it was a disappointing reunion for Campanella and a mediocre episode at best.
19 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Good to see Lew Wickersham. That is Lew, right?
Guad4215 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Joe is hired by the lawyer Noah Atway (Burgess Meredith) who wants Joe to find out who is trying to kill Dr Graham Aspinall (Joseph Campanella), a surgeon who is a leading authority on taking out inoperable tumors. Atway and Joe engage in cute dialogue while Joe is being hired as they take each other's measure. Upon meeting the Doc, Joe finds him uncooperative and insulting. He is a royal pain who doesn't want help. Joe should walk away but he doesn't. (Does he ever?) What follows is a school of red herrings as to who wants the Doc dead. There is the wife Gerta (Carol Olimart) who knows the Doc had a girlfriend and she would inherit everything upon his death. There is the pretty research assistant Charlene (Laraine Stephens) with the jealous boyfriend. There is fellow doctor Felix St Ives (Robert Burr) who lost the girlfriend to the Doc and would be first in line for the Doc's position if the Doc were to die. That girlfriend later committed suicide. There is the lovesick secretary Gloria (Fionnala Flanagan) who the Doc treats badly. The first half of the outing has Joe meeting these suspects but don't waste time keeping track. It is none of them. The hitman trying to get the Doc goes after Joe but misses so now it is personal to Joe. Now Joe learns about patient file 201 and needs to attach a name to it so he can see if there is a connection. This is where a nice twist comes in. Patient 201 is none other than Atway who needs an operation. Turns out he has been doing business with criminals and has documented it all on tapes. The criminals want their hitman to kill the Doc as he is the only one who can do the operation. With him dead, Atway dies of natural causes and it can't be traced back to the criminals. Atway tells Joe where the tapes are, saying that might get him into heaven. While retrieving the tapes, Joe takes out the hitman. The end of the show is Atway getting his operation but not surviving. Joe and the Doc make a tennis date to work through the aftermath. I like Joe's line at the end of turning in the tapes was providing a ticket to heaven for Atway. Nice touch.

As pointed out by other reviewers, logic is taking a long lunch in this episode. Since the Doc is being such a jackass, I assumed he knew exactly who was after him and why. I thought he had done some nefarious deed which brought on this retaliation so he was keeping his mouth shut about it. I was wrong. The fact was the Doc did nothing wrong and had no idea who was after him. In that situation, he should welcome help from any quarter but he is scornful throughout. Also, as pointed out, the lawyer Atway knows exactly what is going on. Since he needs the Doc for his own survival, he would logically come clean with Joe even if he had to admit to handling the finances of criminals. Also, why did the criminal bad guys send one hit man to straighten this out. Considering how important it is, I think they should have freed up three or four more guys. Also, I'm not sure about the criminals' logic in all of this. I get that killing the Doc would also kill Atway but, since Atway knows what is happening, wouldn't he send the tapes to the police once the Doc is dead? I would. Why did file 201 come to the forefront? It gets mentioned out of the blue by the secretary and Joe latches onto it as he tries to put a name to the number. No reason why he should attach such importance to one particular file. Of course, that longshot turns out to be right. Another gut reaction pays off. Take that, Intertect!

The cast is good. Meredith is worth the price of admission by himself. He can get hammy in that good "William Shatner" sort of way. I would have loved to see him as a Mannix villain and watch how close he came to being the Penguin. I like seeing Campanello back but want it to be as Lew Wickersham. Every season, Joe takes a case for a kid, sees an ol' army buddy, visits a bad small town, and avenges a dead fellow PI. He should do an annual case for Intertect. He and Lew can revisit old arguments while working the case together. The rest of the cast, although not big guest stars that Mannix episodes usually have, get the job done.

Joe didn't get drugged or shot and did get paid. Since the lawyer died it was a little bittersweet but still a win for our guy.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
JOE SHOULD HAVE TOLD HIS CLIENT TO SIT ON IT!
tcchelsey10 September 2022
Some heavy hitters are cast in this story, to cover the fact that most of the characters they play are not very likable. Stay tuned...

Of course, when has Mannix ever had an easy ride in the first place? This is what's professionally called a "character study". The story will definitely keep your attention, with Joseph Campanella returning to the series after many years, to play Dr. Aspinall, a distinguished surgeon. The problem is the doc is NOT a people person and guess what-- someone is trying to kill him. Campanella co-starred in the first season of the series as Joe's boss, and more than likely, due to budget constraints, was written out of the show to make way for Gail Fisher as Peggy.

Mannix is introduced to Aspinall by the doc's quirky attorney (Noah Otway), well played by Burgess Meredith, who is another work of art! The list of suspects is interesting. Carol Ohmart (famous for the HOUSE ON HAUNTED HILL) plays Gerda, the doc's wife (who just has that guilty feel) and there's a brief appearance by lovely Lorraine Stephens, always dressed to impress, who reminded me of Anne Francis. Stephens co-starred in the tv action series MATT HELM.

Shimon Wincelberg wrote this story, also many scripts for POLICE WOMAN. Shimon did stories for STAR TREK and GUNSMOKE, a part of tv history.

All in all, another rollercoaster ride, and although the central characters are not particularly suitable for framing, guessing the villain is worth the wait. I agree, Campanella was an excellent actor and gets the job done. SEASON 6 EPISODE 3 CBS/Paramount remastered color dvd box set.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Happy to see Lew back
george_cherucheril3 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Joseph Campanella returns to Mannix for the first time since the end of Season one. He plays Dr. Graham Aspinall. I am glad he returned at least once.

Joseph Campanella was a good actor. He was a victim of bad circumstances. His season one effort playing Lew Wickersham was excellent. The reason he was dropped from the show had nothing to do with his performance. Unfortunately, there was another character on season one that underperformed and needed to go. That character was Intertect, the corporate investigative agency with all the computers to find answers.

Intertect was a product of the late 1960s love affair with spy movies and technology. By 1967 the audience was tired of this. The traditional detective Mannix played well with them but not the technology aspect. The modernistic building filled with huge, soulless machines was a drag on the show. A few years later, the big machines were replaced by smaller machines. Today a lot of that technology is in our smartphones.

Wickersham was the head of Intertect and the two were inextricably linked together. If you get rid of one, you have to get rid of the other. Because of this, Campanella had to leave Mannix. I wish they had brought him back in season three as a new character. He could have been a police lieutenant.

Bringing back Campanella meant he could not be the bad guy or be someone who hates Mannix. As the episode played out, Campanella is prickly but is a good guy. His secretary is head over heels in love with him, but Aspinall is a man of integrity and only has eyes for his wife. I like the final scene where Mannix and Aspinall agree to play tennis together and part as friends.

I was surprised that his character was unfazed when a gunman entered his house in a failed attempt to kill him. It felt like Lew Wickersham was there. Most people would be startled, and his wife Gerda played by Carol Ohmart seemed more worried but not as worried as someone would be if there were gunfire in their house.

I was hoping for a Peggy scene with Aspinall, but it was not to be. Burgess Meredith was great in the episode. I dig the brown wig he wore. Overall, this was an ok episode. I agree with others that the shower scene was too much. Mannix keeps questioning Aspinall as he showers. Lew's been away for years, he lost his job and now you hound the naked man in the shower? Give Lew a break! Let him have some dignity.

Laraine Stephens was great as Charlene Talifer. Her part should have been bigger, and I would have liked to see Mannix hook up with her. Stephens was a stunning woman.

Fionnula Flanagan as secretary Gloria Paget was quite effective. I loved how she flirted with Mannix. Again, another woman who Mannix should have seduced like James Bond would have done to get information.

This episode is average, but it becomes above average with Campanella, Meredith, and Stephens in it. A better script would have made this a great episode. The producers tended to be lazy.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Joe should have kept walking
pkfloydmh13 November 2021
This one is about a doctor who hires Joe to find out who's trying to kill him.

Joe's first inclination was correct when he started to walk out on Otway and he should have kept going and should have stayed miles away from this morass and the idea that he would continue to work for Otway when both Otway and Aspinall are arrogant jerks who are constantly trashing him and refuse to help him at all is implausible and unrealistic. He was even fired at one point but yet continued on with the case, which is absolutely ludicrous.

Another problem is why did Otway hire Joe to begin with when he already knew who was trying to kill Aspinall? Why didn't he just call the police? This is yet another example of Joe getting involved in a case where he isn't needed, so this episode is a complete waste of time. It's also no mystery who the sniper is since he's revealed early on and is seen several times throughout the episode.

Joe doesn't get slugged in the head but does get shot at but not hit. There's a good fight scene towards the end but beyond that there's nothing else to recommend in this flop.

This is a lackluster and dreary episode without much action or excitement but just a lot of talking and speculating and putdowns of Joe and thoroughly despisable characters. There isn't even a murder, which is rare, and as mentioned, Joe isn't even needed since Otway knew all along who was trying to kill Aspinall, so this episode should have never been made. This is the worst episode of the season so far and that now makes three horrendous shows in a row to start the season. Yikes.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed