"Murder, She Wrote" Evidence of Malice (TV Episode 1996) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Deputy Andy's Turning Point, as in Pointed Out to be Turned Against
WeatherViolet8 November 2009
Prolific actor Louis Herthum appears in 25 "MSW" episodes, from a Boston pool player to a Palm Springs law enforcement officer, to his 23 turns as Cabot Cove Deputy from Seasons Eight through Twelve, to hold fourth place in terms of "MSW" episode credits, after Angela Lansbury, William Windom and Ron Masak.

Initially, Louis' recurring run as Cabot Cove Deputy lacks a bit of continuity, as is often the case in series television. Initially credited as "Deputy blank" in Season Eight, he becomes "Deputy Dave Anderson" the second time around although he is addressed as "Andy" on five occasions under the billing of "David," and his character refers to his wife, who remains unseen, and never heard from again.

Before Season Eight runs its course, Louis' character becomes Deputy Andy Broom, a single, gentle, considerate, dedicated law enforcement officer, efficient at his duties, sometimes to the surprise of Sheriff Metzger, who doesn't anticipate Andy's performance expectations before Mort even requests a task. In other words, unlike some Deputies, who are cast as inefficient and clueless, Andy does the job right, before he is even asked. "Got it right here, Sheriff."

But Andy Broom remains a backdrop character, in support of Mort Metzger, for the most part--or at least until now, when it's Deputy Andy's turn to face accusations of suspicion of unethical behavior, retaliation for coercion, and murder in a double homicide centering around a botched Real Estate deal.

Jennifer Parsons guest stars as Patty, Andy's fiancée, with whom he purchases a fixer-upper residence, which the Realtor has misrepresented in terms of points of contention to remedy.

But when bodies begin to surface, after witnesses observe Andy's frustration in dealing with problems, which include bullying by roguish perpetrators, Sheriff Mort Metzger (Ron Masak) asks for the return of Andy's badge, leaving a perplexed Mort unable to defend his comrade, as only Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) would, amid "Evidence of Malice" (a parody title reflecting the film "Absence of Malice").

William Windom returns as Doctor Seth Hazlitt; Stephanie Dunnam appears as Meg Berrigan, after playing Leslie Cameron in Season Three; Rick Lenz returns as Isaac, after, coincidently playing Deputy Jonathan Martin in Season Four, who must also turn in his badge after facing suspicion of murder.

The cast is rounded out by Colleen Coffey as Wendy Arnold, Monica Parker as Hannah Parkins, Zanne Shaw as Customer, Lawrence Monoson as Craig Haber, Tim Ransom as George Parkins, Vyto Ruginis as Fred Berrigan, Mark Voland as Dean Sorenson, Peter Stader as Leverett Boggs, Jack Wright as Deputy Caleb and Tyler Robert Owen as Deputy.

This episode also marks the first and only appearance to date by Tyler Robert Owen, the most recent television appearance to date by Colleen Coffey and Zanne Shaw, and one of most recent for Mark Voland and Jack Wright. Peter Stader ought to be credited on his IMDb Filmography for his role here, but thus far isn't.

Extra points, of course, for the fine performances by Louis Herthum and Ron Masak.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
No malice towards this episode
TheLittleSongbird3 January 2018
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

"Evidence of Malice" gets a lot of credit for finally having Andy as more than the stock underwritten sheriff's deputy character. It centres around him and his struggle to prove his innocence and it was really appreciated, and necessary, to see more development and urgency to him and doing it in a way that allows one to care for him. It is kind of sad however that it took such a long time to happen and considering that it's five episodes before the end of 'Murder She Wrote' it feels somewhat too late.

Louis Herthum does a fine job here, acting with subtlety and charm while still being involved in the drama and giving momentum and emotional weight to the increasing tension. Angela Lansbury is terrific as always, as are William Windom and Ron Masak. All of them work so well together and give the chemistry and situation the urgency and tension it needs.

The mystery is a clever and engaging one, with enough energy to engross and not bore the viewer and with enough to keep one guessing. The denouement was not an easily guessable one which is good, though it could have been better acted.

Production values are slick and stylish. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune. The writing is fun and thought-provoking, not taking itself seriously. Cabot Cove is always a welcome sight.

Despite these many good things, "Evidence of Malice" sadly has a supporting cast that is not up to the leads' level, not even close. The best of them are uninspired and others are amateurish.

Overall, a well done episode that needed a better supporting cast. 8/10 Bethany Cox
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"A mugging in Cabot Cove?"
safenoe4 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Transients".

That was the response to Jessica's bewilderment about the occurrence of a mugging in quiet Cabot Cove. I'm kind of surprised Jessica didn't ponder the possibility of a wall (20 years before its time, as this was a 1996 episode), or NYPD type profiling if you know what I mean.

I don't know if Jessica was being ironic in this episode, but never mind the fact that she has to deal with weekly murders in Cabot Cove that thankfully leads to the arrest of the perpetrator (not a transient) at the end of 60 minutes less commercials. But muggings? Whoa, that really gets Jessica off-track.

The ending was a major surprise, and the double murderer was a big surprise.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good, though the assailant admitted to EVERYTHING way too easily.
planktonrules14 December 2023
When the episode begins, Fred Berrigan is being arrested for driving while intoxicated. He clearly is impaired and there is an open flask of alcohol on the front seat...yet Berrigan swears that the Deputy is setting him up because he hates him. However, Berrigan MAY also be responsible for a murder, as a body is found near where he was stopped by the police. Once again, Berrigan swears the Deputy is out to get him. When Berrigan himself is murdered, folks start thinking the Deputy did it, as Berrigan had insisted the guy was out to get him. Who REALLY did this and why?

This is a decent episode, but it also relies on a bad series cliche...that the real killer admit their guilt. This happens and then they give a long description of all the wicked things they did...which, in real life, hardly ever happens. Still, the show is enjoyable and seeing a dead Berrigan was somehow satisfying.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Evidence of Malice
coltras3513 August 2022
Deputy Andy is first accused of planting evidence in the case of a murdered local businessman, then of being the killer. But of course he's been framed by the killer. An ok episode, but nothing too standout. However, it's hard not bowled over by the charm of the show no matter how below-average or average the episode is.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed