This episode was mostly received negatively by fans and critics, mainly because it is a clip show. Okay, most Simpsons clips shows are pretty bland, I get it, but a 5.4? It really wasn't that bad compared to "All Singing, All Dancing" or "Another Simpsons Clip Show" as both of those clip shows were extremely mediocre.
This episode does not follow the cliche family sitting together thinking about memories in living room or kitchen and tries to create a different plot of everyone celebrating Homer Simpson for his achievements.
I'd have to admit that having Kang and Kodos here kind of ruined the episode as it makes it non-canon, which destroys the purpose of clip shows.
One change they made to one of the clips that I don't like is that they changed Maggie's voice at the part where she says "Daddy", the new voice that was given here doesn't sound as cute as the original.
The best part of the episode by far is the "They'll Never Stop the Simpsons" song, it recaps on all the big moments of the series as well as making fun of ridiculous future plots such as Marge becoming a robot for example, heck, there was even a picture of Homer jumping the shark which shows awareness that the series will eventually jump the shark (again).
Overall, this episode was a little bit dull but it doesn't deserve a lower rating than actual bad episodes of the show.
This episode does not follow the cliche family sitting together thinking about memories in living room or kitchen and tries to create a different plot of everyone celebrating Homer Simpson for his achievements.
I'd have to admit that having Kang and Kodos here kind of ruined the episode as it makes it non-canon, which destroys the purpose of clip shows.
One change they made to one of the clips that I don't like is that they changed Maggie's voice at the part where she says "Daddy", the new voice that was given here doesn't sound as cute as the original.
The best part of the episode by far is the "They'll Never Stop the Simpsons" song, it recaps on all the big moments of the series as well as making fun of ridiculous future plots such as Marge becoming a robot for example, heck, there was even a picture of Homer jumping the shark which shows awareness that the series will eventually jump the shark (again).
Overall, this episode was a little bit dull but it doesn't deserve a lower rating than actual bad episodes of the show.