"Wanted: Dead or Alive" Ransom for a Nun (TV Episode 1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Josh Can't Kick This Habit
GaryPeterson6712 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Another enjoyable episode, one with a lighter touch thanks to Claire Griswold playing the second most annoying nun on television (top dishonor going to Eileen Heckart as Sister Veronica in THE FUGITIVE two-parter "Angels Travel on Lonely Roads"). After Josh successfully engineers Sister Grace's safe release from the criminal gang that kidnapped her, she won't return to the convent, insisting on following Josh like a lost sheep seeking her shepherd. One sympathizes with Josh Randall as he tries again and again but just can't break this habit.

My favorite scene is when Josh is filling his canteen in a scenic river and through the tress comes Sister Grace. He's just about had it with her dogging him across the Arizona desert. Josh explains how the West is "our own private hell" and will continue to be unless she allows him to exterminate the vermin like Lon Kidder. He has a job to do and she has a job to do, and they should each be doing it. It was a fine speech, even if it fell upon deaf ears.

Sister Grace follows Josh all the way to Mission Junction, where the Kidder gang is plotting a bank heist. Seeing Sister Grace there brings Josh to the end of his rope--literally--as he binds and gags her with the church bell rope! She still finds a way to ring the bell, however, alerting the Kidder gang and putting Josh's life at risk. In fact, it would have been the end of Josh had Kidder's gun not inexplicably jammed. Josh glances upward for the explanation, but nonetheless isn't wanting to warm a pew in church the following Sunday, rebuffing kindly the invitation of the safely returned Sister Grace.

Claire Griswold was 21 playing the 17-year-old Sister Grace abducted by Lon Kidder's gang of outlaws. She did have a self assurance and street smart savviness about her one wouldn't expect to find in so young a nun. And as much as she insisted she was following Josh to prevent gunplay and his death from haunting her conscience, I suspected she was thoroughly enjoying the thrill of it all. In the end, I just couldn't see Sister Grace taking final vows and settling for a quiet, contemplative life.

In reality Griswold was married to actor-cum-director Sidney Pollack for just shy of 50 years when he passed away in 2008 (Griswold died in 2011 at age 74). She has surprisingly few credits for a woman as well spoken and attractive as this appearance led me to expect.

This episode was the first of six to be scripted by Fred Freiberger, later the infamous producer of STAR TREK's third season. He captured well the character of Josh Randall, from his reluctance to take the job, his striking a bargain with the sheriff, playing hardball in the prisoner exchange, and his long-suffering patience and exasperation with the increasingly irksome Sister Grace.

McQueen and Griswold enjoyed an easy chemistry as friendly adversaries. Also noteworthy was Hugh Sanders in his scene as a sheriff eager to unload Kidder but wary of unloading him onto Randall, whom he knows has a plan to bargain for the nun's release. A good even if not great episode, which is still high praise since this series consistently set the bar high.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Pretty good... for first season!
rickz25 April 2010
Part of this episode was filmed in Old Tucson... I recognize the shot of the Mission (you can see it in /Rio Bravo/ ) The saguaro's are obviously from around Tucson. After you watch a few of these episodes, you learn to recognize the same old town, with a few signs changed to let you know that a) All of these western towns look alike and b) A sign painter could make a pretty good living following Josh around!!

Old Tucson is different. It doesn't have the same old dead-end street!!!

The nun is interesting... sort of flirting with Josh. (Was that fair??) Some of these first episodes have been pretty ho-hum, but I liked this one. (My sweetie didn't.)

Senor Reek, Tombstone, AZ
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great show with good plot and acting
headhunter4615 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I always liked this show. The concept of a bounty hunter with a conscience who prefers to bring the criminals back alive to stand trial is an excellent one.

Josh is honest, fair, but tough as nails when necessary. The show doesn't make him out to be a super hero, just a guy who wants to make the west a safer place to live and make some money in the process. He often gives money to the victims of outlaws he brings back, not in this particular episode but in several.

In this episode he pretends he will take a prisoner to another town all the while intending to turn him over to his band of outlaws who are holding a 17 year old nun as hostage in return for their gang member. Josh knows he will have to find a way to regain custody of the convicted outlaw or the law will issue a warrant for him. He had a plan but the nun he rescued decides she is now responsible for his life and follows him much to his dismay. Without intending to, she is putting his life at greater risk by her presence. He finally gets so frustrated he ties her up in a church where he has located the outlaws. But she is so determined to "help" she rings the church bell and alerts the outlaws. This lady is just too naive to live in the old west. Josh manages to save the day in spite of her "help" and delivers her safely to the mother superior.

The woman who played the nun was adorable and had a very nice voice. I thought certain she would be in many other shows and possibly make it into big cinema. She was in numerous TV shows until 1963 when Sydney Pollack discovered her and managed to convince her to marry him. Lucky guy. She was in one more episode of Bonanza in 1967 and then retired. She and Sydney had two daughters and one son.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Sister Grace
Easygoer1020 March 2019
It's hard to believe the nun "Sister Grace", played by Claire Griswald (spelled "Griswold") went on to marry famed director Sydney Pollack only a few years later in 1963. She never acted afterwards, and were married 50 years, when Sydney Pollack died in 2003. She died a few years later.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Annoying nun
If the nun was as annoying when the bad guys had her... they would have let her go and saved us all this episode.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Two Mules for Sister Grace?
Johnny_West26 December 2023
Way before Clint Eastwood and Shirley MacLaine heated things up with "Two Mules for Sister Sara" in 1970, Steve McQueen and Claire Griswold (as Sister Grace) were flirting with each other in "Ransom for a Nun."

Nuns were in other TV Westerns of that era, such as Daniel Boone (The Fleeing Nuns), Bronco (Brand of Courage), Wagon Train (The Sister Rita Story), Bonanza (A Question of Strength), Gunsmoke (The Sisters), and probably a few others. Like in other TV episodes featuring nuns, Sister Grace was meddling in the affairs of the gunslingers, by trying to bend them to do things in a peaceful manner.

In this case, the outlaws kidnap Sister Grace to trade her for a captured buddy. The local sheriff, played by Hugh Sanders, is more than happy to put outlaw George Brenlin in the hands of McQueen. He then trades the outlaw for the nun, and finds out that he cannot get rid of the nun.

Sister Grace wants to make sure that McQueen is gentle with the outlaws. She ends up becoming a major impediment in capturing the outlaws, while spending a lot of time being sweet and persuasive with McQueen. Was she really so concerned about the outlaws, or was she more interested in McQueen?
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed