Love for Sale (2006) User Reviews

Slow but rewarding film on non-conformity

[debblyst · 7/10 · 13 January 2007]

"O Céu de Suely" follows Hermila (Hermila Guedes), a strong-willed and strong-faced young woman who leaves the big city of São Paulo with her infant son to return to her home town Iguatu, in the hot, arid hinterland of Ceará (Northeastern Brazil), where perennial blue skies never bring the rain. It's a poor village, but not the kind of desolate poverty of the peripheries and favelas of big Brazilian towns; life in Iguatu is simple, humble, uneventful, but unplagued by violence or famine. Hermila moves back into her grandmother's modest house, where her young aunt also lives (Hermila's parents are never mentioned). We learn that Hermila is impatiently waiting for Mateus, her companion (and the father of her child), to join her. Her baby's constant crying unnerves her: half- jokingly, she says she sometimes wishes she could leave him behind, "somewhere in the woods". Hermila's not evil or an uncaring mother -- she's just 21, eager, self-centered, she wants to have fun.

Life in Iguatu is boring. At night, she thinks of how much she's in love with Mateus and how she misses sex with him. While she waits, Hermila hangs out with Georgina, a young prostitute –- they both enjoy dancing, drinking, karaokeing, laughing, flirting, smoking pot. Hermila also meets biker João: they have casual sex, and though she's just having fun, he falls in love with her. Hermila soon realizes Mateus is never going to show up or send her money to help her raise their son. She's now on her own with her baby. She decides to leave Iguatu once again to a Southern city "as far as possible from Iguatu", but she can't afford the bus ticket. She raffles a bottle of whiskey, but the money she collects is insignificant. So she decides to raffle her own body for "a night in paradise" (as Sophia Loren did in DeSica's episode "La Riffa" in Boccaccio 70). She's excited by the idea and even comes up with a nom-de-guerre: Suely.

The raffle news runs fast: she becomes the talk of the town, physically confronted by neighbors, strangers and even her own grandmother (in one of the film's best scenes), who calls her a prostitute. Hermila/Suely hits back: "I'm no prostitute; prostitutes go with lots of men, I'll go with just ONE". She's naive; she doesn't know what she's doing is against the law. Even her open-minded aunt can't understand her; if Hermila's family is willing to help her and her baby, if João loves her and is ready to commit, what else does she want? Hermila doesn't know WHAT exactly, but she knows she wants more than quiet, uneventful survival. Is she going all the way with the raffle? Will she leave again? What about her family, her son, João?

4 years after his visceral (but irregular) "Madame Satã" set in 1930s Rio de Janeiro, Ceará-born director/co-writer Karim Aïnouz investigates in "Céu…" a reality much closer to him: the back-land of Northeastern Brazil, where male migration is a century-long tradition due to the arid weather and poor soil; they migrate South looking for work and ways to send money back home. Women are used to living by themselves, doing menial jobs and running their homes and families (sisters, daughters, nieces, small children). Like in all small villages in all poor countries, migration is the magical promise of happiness, of a better fate, of CHANGE. The men you do see in Iguatu are just passing by in their bikes, trucks, cars -- the gas station is the place where local girls meet men in transit. In Iguatu, the skies are immobile and life stands still; the road is the only place where there's action.

Like Stablemate aptly said in his comment here, "Céu…" is centered around acting (and mood) rather than narrative development or plot twists. And at its center is actress Hermila Guedes. Though little experienced, she gives one of the guttiest, nakedest (in every sense) performances in recent Brazilian cinema. Aïnouz is obviously fascinated with her strong face (there are close-ups of her eyes, mouth, teeth, hair, there's even a close-up of the skin behind her ear!), her magnificent, ample bosom and girlish hips and legs. The other actors deliver competently, with Zezita Mattos a standout as the grandmother. Walter Carvalho's camera-work is efficient as usual and serves the film completely; seldom have blue skies seemed so claustrophobic. The costume/hair design is spot-on, with Hermila-Suely's clothes gradually revealing more of her body, and her "big city" hairstyle becoming a symbol of her inadequacy in Iguatu. The soundtrack smartly alternates tacky Brazilian love songs with experimental electronic music.

In" Madame Satã", Aïnouz depicted a black gay swindler who used his nimble, powerful body to fight, dance, cross-dress, seduce, gain respect. Like "Satã", "Céu..." also focuses on a non-conformist, independent protagonist who uses the body to defy society and express personal freedom: freeing the body as a symbol of freeing and strengthening oneself. "Céu..." is a quietly rewarding film, certainly slow but powerful and coherent in its apparent uneventfulness. Recommended for attentive, patient viewers and for those who want to watch recent Brazilian films NOT dealing with urban violence and favelas.

Well worth watching, for those not easily bored.

[Stablemate · 7/10 · 26 November 2006]

Brazil is starting to make itself known in the international film world. With a couple of films ('Cidade de Deus' most importantly) in recent years becoming international successes, a new Brazilian film may today have a bigger chance than ever before of getting good international distribution. Although 'O Céu de Suely' definitely deserves reaching a wider audience than the cinephile crowd, it will certainly not become a blockbuster. It's a slow, thoughtful, angst ridden movie with controversial themes.

The main character in 'O Céu de Suely' is Hermila, a poor young mother returning from the big city of Sao Paulo to her small hometown and the family she left behind abruptly a few years earlier when becoming pregnant. She returns home involuntarily because city life has not worked out for her but she does not intend to stay. 'O Céu de Suely' is not 'Cidade de Deus' and its setting is not the favela, which is nice as a contrast to most other Brazilian films reaching these shores. Neither is it, like the many Brazilian soaps, set among the wealthy in the gated communities in Rio de Janeiro and Sao Paulo. Its setting is a small, underdeveloped town where the best one can hope for is drawing the winning ticket in a raffle.

Hermila is young and naive but also strong minded and resourceful. She loves her infant son, the grandmother who raised her and the aunt who is her closest friend in her hometown but she is really a self-centered person who can not set her own needs and desires aside for those of her loved ones. She feels the need to escape the mundane life and limited opportunities of the small town. Like millions of poor Brazilians, and poor people in rural areas around the world, she dreams of another life, somewhere else. But she needs some money to get going. Setting up a raffle with a bottle of whisky as prize can get her some money but not nearly enough. Hermila is beautiful, lively and attractive and she knows it. She can see that her body is her most valuable asset in the society she lives in. But can she use that asset to get somewhere without losing too much of her dignity and the respect of her family? Does she care, or can she simply ignore the conventions of the people around her? Is there a way to get past the limited options seemingly available to her? And is love a possibility or just another trap?

'O Céu de Suely' is a movie that favors naturalistic acting before big narrative developments and plot twists. The camera work is slow and beautiful. The characters, all bearing the same name as their actors, feel very real. The focus of the film is not on the starving but on people who are not needing the necessities of life but the things beyond that. The wealthy are not at all present here but we don't need to see them. We know the world is unequal and we know Brazil is one of the most unequal societies in the world. This film is a welcome illumination of that society and the most world-changing force today - the urban migration. It is also a quite nice film about one particular woman and her painful choices. Worth watching if you're not easily bored.

Lackluster abandon

[Chris Knipp · 7/10 · 6 May 2007]

'Love for sale,' following Aïnouz's moody, unusual 'Madame Satã' , is again about a marginal, uncertain character, a young woman who flirts with prostitution while left with the raising of a young child, but this time the result is less of a success, though the Brazilian director does achieve a raw neorealist flavor and the images, though sometimes grainy, are colorful and well-lit.

Hermila (Hermila Guedes) leaves Sao Paulo and returns to the little town she came from expecting Mateus, her boyfriend, to follow. He never does, and she stays with her grandmother and her young aunt or hangs out with her young friend Georgina (Georgina Castro), who turns tricks. When Mateus doesn't turn up and she learns he's disappeared, she switches from selling raffle tickets for a bottle of whisky to selling ones for herself, or as she calls it, for "a night in paradise," planning to go as far as she can away, somewhere in the direction of Porto Allegre, when she's raised the money to do so. An old boyfriend, João (João Miguel) starts making love to her and says he's mad about her, and Hermila goes along with it, but she's not really interested. When her grandmother finds out about the raffle tickets she gets rough and Hermila leaves for a while; grandma and auntie take care of Mateus junior. Hermila turns a trick or two and eventually gets together enough money to leave town, and she leaves Mateus junior behind. João rather pathetically follows the bus on his motorcycle for a bit, then circles around and comes back. And that's about it.

It's not too clear what Aïnouz was trying to achieve in this film. Visuals are sometimes striking in their evocation of heat and a relentless sun and capture authentic scenery and people, but the action is desultory at best. 'Madame Satã' had a big advantage: a colorful main character, based on a real person, João Francisco dos Santos, with an interesting story and a go-for-broke performance by the remarkable Lázaro Ramos in the lead. With her elegant cheekbones and beautiful body, Hermila Guedes is convincing enough as someone men would buy raffle tickets for, and she projects a range of emotion from despair to wild abandon, but her character is unformed and uncertain and the meandering story focused on her provides little to react to or ponder.

Shown as part of the San Francisco International Film Festival 2007.