The Hinterlands (TV Mini Series 2013– ) Poster

(2013– )

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Sticks & stones and insipid slogans
Suradit22 August 2014
This is an excellent look at the damage done to young people by relentless bullying and name calling. It is presented in a series of shorts, much of the narration sung by Paul who is the main focus of the film and of the bullying. It demonstrates quite accurately how school can be torture for those students who are made to feel bad about themselves because they are deemed unattractive or bad at sports or not academically strong or if, like Paul, they are gay.

Paul says that he is interested in theoretical physics, which suggests he ought to thrive in a school environment where learning ought to be fostered. Because he feels so miserable at school, he's not doing that well in classes and his sense of self-worth is rock bottom. He wonders aloud if he wouldn't be better off dead & buried rather than enduring this daily torment.

The old adage: "Sticks and stones will break my bones, But words will never harm me," is demonstrably false when those damaging words are heard day after day without let up . The portrayal of the damage done to young people who are forced to live in a bullying environment year after year in school while trying to get an education and to develop social skills is very well done, but if this series is meant to offer hope and to raise the spirits of those who suffer the bullying, I doubt it will have much of an impact.

The message "You are worthy of love" is nice and hopefully will make some kids feel better about themselves. The add-on messages from the Trevor Foundation telling at risk kids to call and talk to someone if they are thinking of suicide will hopefully save some lives, but I have my doubts that either will do much for many kids who experience the daily hell of high school and who are the targets of constant bullying and name calling.

At that age most kids are seeking peer approval and acceptance and a sense that they fit in. Being reminded daily that most of your peers consider you a joke, a fag, a retard and a loser is not going to be magically made better by reciting the slogan "I am worthy" or talking to an adult who says something akin to the "sticks and stones" nonsense or that "a little bullying will make you stronger."

At the very least, kids who are bullied are made to feel like crap for years on end. The opportunity to learn in a supportive environment is stolen from them, so they will be negatively impacted for the balance of their lives in many cases. And in some cases they decide enough is enough and run away from home, from school and maybe from life. The problem is not the kids being bullied and it won't be solved by writing slogans saying "I am worthy" or proclaiming "It gets better." The students who bully and the adults supposedly managing the school environment are at fault and remediation needs to be aimed at them.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Great coping mechanism. Falters a bit with writing.
otpisanyone10 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The Hinterlands is something I like to see. A lot of Gay Short Films are about dating and Romance or about how awful it is for gay people. This is a little bit of that second category. However, those films are usually driven by plot over character. The Hinterlands does not have a very interesting plot. A nerdy high-school student gets bullied for being gay. He stops getting bullied when he joins the volleyball team, but that doesn't last for very long. He contemplates suicide and visits the grave of someone who did. A wise man comes and tells him that he's a great person and everything's all nifty now. The dialogue and lyrics also tend to falter occasionally, coming of as a bit too blunt. People nowadays either try to be subtle or just shout awful things at you. For the most part the bullies fit this mold, but even then, it's not very realistic. I'm actually dealing with similar problems (although to a lesser degree) and this doesn't mirror real life very effectively.

So, what do I like about this series? Paul. This, too me, is what most films that try to tackle this subject fail at. Creating a relatable main character. Most main characters in gay short films are perfect human beings who are good at everything and who would be popular if they were straight to help further emphasize how awful the discriminatory characters are. Paul is incredibly awkward and passionate about theoretical physics. He has very low self esteem and doesn't really understand, let alone have, social skills. If you replaced Paul with any main character of almost any gay short film then this would be a chore to sit through, but it's not. You're willing to overlook the faulty dialogue and the sometimes "cringe-inducing" lyrics because you want him to have his happy ending. You want to see him grow.The songs are also effective (again if you can look past some iffy lyrics). Connor Russel's voice is amazing, and the melodies are simple, but great at matching the text behind them.

All in all, this series isn't perfect, but it's great if you're going through similar issues, or even if you just want to have a good cry. I would definitely recommend it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed