first off, all the people claiming this to be an important and accurate piece of social commentary on todays Britain are way way off the mark. yes there are council estates where nasty characters such as those portrayed in this film do reside, and yes they are a deplorable stain on our society, BUT that does not mean the answer lies in shooting them all in the face!
The straight forward knuckle-headed logic within Harry Brown and the eagerness of audiences to cry out their approval (people were whooping and hollering in the screening i went to - mostly, i may add, middle aged) demonstrates a shockingly widespread and simplistic view of this problem. People have no interest in the problem itself, no desire to hear of back-story (which in fairness to the film-makers was probably left out to not convolute the plot too much - though the film suffers greatly from this entirely one-sided approach) of the kids on these estates or to hear ideas of long term solutions - not that i'm suggesting i know better than others, but surely there's more effective answers than the Rambo styled 'let's go shoot all the bastards!'
The broad strokes with which the characters are drawn in this film works great for the plot. From Plan B's gang leader to the gun-selling-cannabis grower, all are horrendous and utterly despicable people - making them easy to hate and feel little sympathy for when Harry does away with them - 'always maintain your weapons' being the best scene in the film. After that it all goes rapidly down hill.
The comment on the police force is confused, seemingly wanting to say that they are ineffectual and provocative in areas like these but without going into any reasons or intelligent thought on the matter. Just that they are. That seems to be what Harry Brown is saying all over - that they just are bad and that he is good and we like it when he kills them cos then he can walk under the road safely. The End - except its not is it? you can't shoot a social problem to rid it, life is not that simple. We may all wish for an easy answer but this isn't it. Trust me, i'm from a ghetto-ised area of Sheffield, I have seen firsthand the effect guns and violence have had on my area and it is not good. It says a lot about British people's mentality that this film has done so well, and while i don't blame the opportunistic film-makers, i am worried about the state of our nation who have greedily lapped it up.
On the plus side though, the film looks great.
The straight forward knuckle-headed logic within Harry Brown and the eagerness of audiences to cry out their approval (people were whooping and hollering in the screening i went to - mostly, i may add, middle aged) demonstrates a shockingly widespread and simplistic view of this problem. People have no interest in the problem itself, no desire to hear of back-story (which in fairness to the film-makers was probably left out to not convolute the plot too much - though the film suffers greatly from this entirely one-sided approach) of the kids on these estates or to hear ideas of long term solutions - not that i'm suggesting i know better than others, but surely there's more effective answers than the Rambo styled 'let's go shoot all the bastards!'
The broad strokes with which the characters are drawn in this film works great for the plot. From Plan B's gang leader to the gun-selling-cannabis grower, all are horrendous and utterly despicable people - making them easy to hate and feel little sympathy for when Harry does away with them - 'always maintain your weapons' being the best scene in the film. After that it all goes rapidly down hill.
The comment on the police force is confused, seemingly wanting to say that they are ineffectual and provocative in areas like these but without going into any reasons or intelligent thought on the matter. Just that they are. That seems to be what Harry Brown is saying all over - that they just are bad and that he is good and we like it when he kills them cos then he can walk under the road safely. The End - except its not is it? you can't shoot a social problem to rid it, life is not that simple. We may all wish for an easy answer but this isn't it. Trust me, i'm from a ghetto-ised area of Sheffield, I have seen firsthand the effect guns and violence have had on my area and it is not good. It says a lot about British people's mentality that this film has done so well, and while i don't blame the opportunistic film-makers, i am worried about the state of our nation who have greedily lapped it up.
On the plus side though, the film looks great.
Tell Your Friends