I don't know where to start honestly, this was easily the most anticipated TV episode of all time aside from the upcoming final episode and to see the way it turned out, it just.... I honestly don't have the word to describe it cause even disappointment just doesn't cut it.
The episode didn't have much plot or dialogue since it's a very battle heavy episode, so there isn't much to criticize there, so I'll just list all the things I didn't like in this episode.
1. The lighting in the episode was terrible, I could barely see any of the action even after turning up my brightness all the way up. I don't know if it was because they didn't have the budget for the CGI or what but this is easily the most biggest and ambitious battle of the show, not being able to follow the action is just inexcusable.
2. The episode had huge plot armors, not a single main character died. It's insane how there were 2 Targaryens, 3 Starks, 2 Lannisters and somehow every single one of them managed to come out of it unscathed.
3. The Night Kings end was very disappointing, 7 seasons of buildup and this is how he meets his end? The Great War, more like The Great Battle. Seriously why even it call it the great war if you were going to just kill him after one episode. What happened to all the petty squabbles in Westeros taking a back seat to the real threat?
4. What was the point of Bran? We keep seeing his eyes turn white as he wargs/greenseers like he is about to do something big and you expect some sort of huge twist or game changing moment in the show but nada, nothing. All he does is give Arya the dagger and use a bunch of crows to lure the Night King towards him. They build him up as this massively important god like figure that will play a big role in the White Walker story but nope, no warging into a Dragon, no warging into the Nightking, no greenseeing into the first Long Night and talking to the Night King, nothing.
5. Arya is one of my favorite characters in the show but her killing the Night King didn't sit right with me, what happened to all the Azor Ahai, the whole Prince that was promised, lightbringer prophecy. What's the point of bringing back Jon from the dead if he wasn't going to do anything, what was the point of Rhaegar divorcing his wife, marrying Lyana and plunging the realm into war, seriously the entire events of Game of Thrones happened because he believed his son would become the Prince that was promised and save the world and now you're telling me he did all that for nothing.
6. The writing of the show is abysmal now, Arya jumping out of nowhere to kill the Night King, Jorah surviving a hundred stabs and still standing, the Dothrakhi charging into battle without any plan, the dragons moving around in the clouds for 10 minutes aimlessly, Jon surviving against hundreds of white walkers, there is just so much bad writing it just makes you want tear your hair out.
Even after all this, I will say though there were still some good things in the episode. Theon's story was just brilliant and this episode ended his arc perfectly, this is a character that has struggled with his identity for most of his life, constantly trying to reconcile his loyalty to his family and his allegiance to the Starks. He has been a coward for most of his life because of that and that has led him to committing some really heinous acts, which he has been trying to repent for ever since. And seeing him finally be brave in the face of overwhelming adversity, knowing for certain he is about to die cements his character arc as one of the best.
The episode was also well directed with good performances and despite not being able see the battle that well, you could still sense the epicness and scale of the battle, so props to the director for that.
13 out of 17 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends