Directors with whom I am not in tune

by neil-476 | created - 14 Apr 2014 | updated - 05 Aug 2016 | Public

This list is not for directors of the Ed Wood variety - I'm not concerned with directors whose negligible competence is outpaced by their enthusiasm. Rather, it is for directors who are undoubtedly very able, but who leave me completely mystified as to their appeal even though I may - and I emphasise "may" - have enjoyed parts of their body of work. Their films have comments from people who praise them to the heights while I am left thinking "Emperor's New Clothes." I simply don't get them.

1. Darren Aronofsky

Writer | Pi

Darren Aronofsky was born February 12, 1969, in Brooklyn, New York. Growing up, Darren was always artistic: he loved classic movies and, as a teenager, he even spent time doing graffiti art. After high school, Darren went to Harvard University to study film (both live-action and animation). He won ...

While I appreciate that certain films are well-crafted - Requiem, Wrestler, Swan - I just plain didn't like them: I made no emotional connection with them at all. The Fountain, of course, was pretentious rubbish. And who knows what on earth was going on with Noah?

2. Zack Snyder

Director | 300

Zachary Edward "Zack" Snyder (born March 1, 1966) is an American film director, film producer, and screenwriter, best known for action and science fiction films. Snyder made his feature film debut with the 2004 remake Dawn of the Dead and has gone on to be known for his comic book movies and ...

I had great hopes for Zack Snyder - I liked both 300 and Watchmen. But as his career moves on it becomes more and more clear that, while he has an undoubted gift for putting eye-boggling visuals on screen, he should be kept well away from typewriter keyboards. Sucker Punch was adolescent tripe, and Man Of Steel changed, for the (much) worse, a character who had been perfectly fine for 75 years. He is a menace when writing his own material.

3. Joel Coen

Producer | The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

Joel Daniel Coen is an American filmmaker who regularly collaborates with his younger brother Ethan. They made Raising Arizona, Barton Fink, Fargo, The Big Lebowski, True Grit, O Brother Where Art Thou?, Burn After Reading, A Serious Man, Inside Llewyn Davis, Hail Caesar and other projects. Joel ...

Ah, the Coen brothers. I can't say I haven't enjoyed any of their films, although I CAN say that I haven't enjoyed all of them. And what I really dislike is the feeling that the two of them are sitting in a corner, sniggering at a private joke to which I am not party.

4. Ethan Coen

Producer | The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

The younger brother of Joel, Ethan Coen is an Academy Award and Golden Globe winning writer, producer and director coming from small independent films to big profile Hollywood films. He was born on September 21, 1957 in Minneapolis, Minnesota. In some films of the brothers- Ethan & Joel wrote, Joel...

See above

5. Mick Garris

Writer | Amazing Stories

Born in Santa Monica, California, on December 4, 1951, Mick Garris grew up with his mother in the San Fernando Valley neighborhood of Van Nuys from age 12, following his parents' divorce. Garris was making his own 8mm home movies around that time, and when he got older be became a freelance critic ...

Having taken a number of fine Stephen King works and transformed them into audiovisual mush, his talents appear to be best suited to directing episodes of cookie cutter TV series. I hesitate to use the term "journeyman hack", but I just did. Plus he has a Very Bad Haircut.

6. Ridley Scott

Producer | The Martian

Described by film producer Michael Deeley as "the very best eye in the business", director Ridley Scott was born on November 30, 1937 in South Shields, Tyne and Wear. His father was an officer in the Royal Engineers and the family followed him as his career posted him throughout the United Kingdom ...

Ridley Scott's early films annoyed me. Alien, Legend, Blade Runner all showed me that he was without compare at putting on screen realistic worlds I had never seen, but he was also very bad at storytelling - all three films were seriously flawed in terms of pacing and narrative. As this was perhaps due to studio interference I forgave him. A bit. Then came Robin Hood (the origin) and, oh merciful heavens, Prometheus, which looked great but forgot to make any sense at all.

7. Christopher Nolan

Writer | Tenet

Best known for his cerebral, often nonlinear, storytelling, acclaimed Academy Award winner writer/director/producer Sir Christopher Nolan CBE was born in London, England. Over the course of more than 25 years of filmmaking, Nolan has gone from low-budget independent films to working on some of the ...

I'm not 100% happy about adding Nolan to the list as I have enjoyed his films (while remaining aware of their faults: cold-bloodedness and bombast, to name but two). The reason he is here is because of the evangelism of those who sing his praises: it was a Batman film, not the Second Coming. And I deplore the Nolanisation of Superman - the very fact that "Nolanisation" has been coined as a neologism is enough to get my goat - although perhaps the responsibility for that lies towards the start of this list (Snyder, in case you're wondering).

8. Woody Allen

Writer | Annie Hall

Woody Allen was born on November 30, 1935, as Allen Konigsberg, in The Bronx, NY, the son of Martin Konigsberg and Nettie Konigsberg. He has one younger sister, Letty Aronson. As a young boy, he became intrigued with magic tricks and playing the clarinet, two hobbies that he continues today.

Allen ...

Woody Allen, legendary humourist and darling of the intellectual classes, shifted from comedies to serious films. But his comedies (mostly) weren't funny and his serious films are peopled with characters who are not much fun to be around. Despite the fact that I have from time to time enjoyed some of his films (or, more accurately, parts of them), I remain largely without empathy for whatever is going on in his head.

9. Quentin Tarantino

Writer | Reservoir Dogs

Quentin Jerome Tarantino was born in Knoxville, Tennessee. His father, Tony Tarantino, is an Italian-American actor and musician from New York, and his mother, Connie (McHugh), is a nurse from Tennessee. Quentin moved with his mother to Torrance, California, when he was four years old.

In January of...

Ah, Quentin effing Tarantino. A gifted screenwriter, a very able director, but unfortunately a man who is fatally chained to a number of major flaws, of which the main one is a belief in his own publicity which leads him to massive self-indulgence. A man who misunderstands "less is more" to mean "more is even more." And a taste for trash cinema doesn't mean that you have to use it to underwrite everything you do.

10. Noah Baumbach

Writer | The Squid and the Whale

Born in Brooklyn in 1969 Noah Baumbach is the son of two film critics, Georgia Brown and Jonathan Baumbach (also a writer). His studies at Vassar College were the subject of his first film (made as he was 26 years old), Kicking and Screaming (1995). His second major picture, made ten years later, ...

He seems to have a gift for making films which are badged as comedies but aren't. I find him smug, self-satisfied, and sour.

11. Nicolas Winding Refn

Writer | The Neon Demon

Writer, director, and producer Nicolas Winding Refn was born in Copenhagen, Denmark, in 1970, to Anders Refn, a film director and editor, and Vibeke Winding (née Tuxen), a cinematographer. Just before he turned 11, in 1981, he moved to New York with his parents, where he lived out his teen years. ...

Another one with a devoted following who accuse you of being too stupid to understand if you find his films to be vacuous and tedious. A director for whom the expression "Emperor's New Clothes" would have had to be invented if it hadn't already existed. Sometimes an extended pause doesn't add dramatic value, it just screws up the pacing of your film.



Recently Viewed