"Hogan's Heroes" Operation Tiger (TV Episode 1970) Poster

(TV Series)

(1970)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Measure of Justice for Tiger
darryl-tahirali27 June 2023
The first of the four memorable recurring characters writer Richard Powell created for "Hogan's Heroes" was "Tiger," introduced in the second-ever episode "Hold That Tiger," the French underground leader who was brave, resourceful, and, as played by exotic beauty Arlene Martel, sexy. Unfortunately, Tiger, who appeared in just five episodes, quickly became a damsel in distress reduced by Season Two's "Heil Klink" to a doe-eyed kitten fretfully clutching her handkerchief when she wasn't simpering at Hogan. (Martel appeared in two other episodes as other underground agents more substantial than what Tiger had become.)

Why Powell relegated Tiger to the margins is unknown, but by Season Six writer Laurence Marks seemed seized by chivalry and attempted to restore her honor with "Operation Tiger," an effort that ultimately finds the underground leader still a damsel in distress in need of rescue--again--although Marks does partially succeed in providing a measure of justice for Tiger; if anything, at least he gives her a real name: Marie Louise Monet.

Learning that Tiger has been arrested by the Gestapo, Colonel Hogan, leading the intelligence and sabotage unit that operates covertly from Stalag 13, asks London for permission to stage a rescue operation; however, when his request is denied, he decides to undertake one anyway, offering impassioned speech about her importance to the war effort and how she saved his own life just a month previously. Initially reluctant to follow, the Heroes do join with their leader to rescue Tiger, who is being taken on a train to Berlin for a kangaroo trial and a quick execution.

As other reviewers have noted, the rescue is both familiar and anticlimactic, but in its final season, "Hogan's Heroes" had had every drop of originality squeezed out of it. Furthermore, Marks didn't give Martel much to as Tiger spends much of her time passively handcuffed to a pair of Gestapo agents, with only one scene giving her substantial dialog--and that is interspersed with making out with Hogan.

And given the near-melodrama of the moment, there aren't many opportunities for humor, with those largely given to Carter as Larry Hovis rehashes his wacky-German-officer shtick, even calling grim, imperious Gestapo Captain Steiger (noted television heavy Frank Marth, largely used for ballast here) "buddy." One witty moment does occur during colloquy over confiscated alleged "wood alcohol" that would be "suicide" to drink between Hogan and Stalag 13 commandant Colonel Klink, who deadpans that no one is allowed to commit suicide without written permission. When Hogan's quips that it must be three signed copies, Klink's comeback is, no, it's "four copies. One goes to Berlin."

Laurence Marks never forgot that the context for the show is Nazi Germany during World War Two, and Klink's line is a clever swipe at the bureaucracy the Nazis were as fanatical about as their anti-Semitism. Moreover, Marks's scripts, even the flawed, tired one he wrote for "Operation Tiger," still displayed an internal logic and assured writing that maintained fundamental narrative competence, particularly when delivering a measure of justice for Tiger.

REVIEWER'S NOTE: What makes a review "helpful"? Every reader of course decides that for themselves. For me, a review is helpful if it explains why the reviewer liked or disliked the work or why they thought it was good or not good. Whether I agree with the reviewer's conclusion is irrelevant. "Helpful" reviews tell me how and why the reviewer came to their conclusion, not what that conclusion may be. Differences of opinion are inevitable. I don't need "confirmation bias" for my own conclusions. Do you?
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Been there, Done that
kfo949410 September 2014
This is a routine script as another undercover agent has been captured by the Gestapo and they just happen to be passing close to Stalag 13. Hogan will make a grand plan that will hopefully free the agent.

The only thing different in this tale is that the underground agent happens to be a woman named Tiger that had saved Hogan's life a few years ago. London advised that it was too dangerous and told Hogan and his men not attempt her escape. But Hogan, the gentleman that he is, cannot resist a female in distress and violates orders to try and free the woman from the hands of the Gestapo.

There is nothing in this script that stirs much interest. It felt like so many episodes in the past but only the names had been changed. I feel sure when the writers have to come up with twenty-five scripts per year that some are going to be closely repeated. Yet, we do not need to give them a round of applause for a script that has already been done. Here is hoping for a fresh scripts to finish the final season of the series.
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Script seemed padded, but without much humor
FlushingCaps15 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Here we have Hogan learning that the female Underground leader Tiger, seen in a few episodes over the years (and the actress seen briefly in a couple of minor roles in between) has been captured by the Gestapo and is being taken by train to Berlin where she is expected to be questioned and executed.

Hogan has Baker radio London for permission to try to rescue her, but is told not to because it is too dangerous. Since she knows all about Hogan's operation, and she could crack under the infamous Gestapo methods, you'd think London would be ordering Hogan to break up shop, destroy anything that could be useful to the Krauts, and have all of his men return to England.

Instead, Hogan is to just let Tiger be executed. But of course, he will ignore orders and try to rescue her, first on his own since his men are believing in the danger and in following orders, then with the whole gang going along to help their boss.

Hogan gets Carter to pose as a local German official and they stop the train and Carter tells the head man, a Captain Steiger, that the track and many roads nearby are all mined. He successfully gets him to decide to take his prisoner to Stalag 13 to temporarily house her until the tracks are safe again.

Once that happens, Hogan is able to talk to Tiger while she is in the cooler, but cannot rescue her safely there. He decides to let her go back onto the train and they'll spring her that way.

Now earlier, the rescue was said to be impossible, I believe at least two times because as Hogan exaggerated, "every Gestapo man in Germany will be guarding her." We know he didn't mean it literally. Yet now, because he has no clever scheme like he usually does, he decides that just he and Newkirk in German uniforms, supposedly ordered to backup the men on the train, can do the job.

They show papers to one man on the train, then are permitted to enter the compartment next to where Tiger is being held by two guards, including the captain. In this compartment are two other guards. This seems to be all the people actually guarding Tiger-two with her, and two next door. Hogan and Newkirk pull guns on the two where they are, tied them up and gag them, then go through the connecting door into the compartment with Tiger where they easily overpower the other two, then lead Tiger out the window while the train is stopped once again. They end up with everyone looking with field glasses to see the train blown up by dynamite.

Before all of this drama happens, we sit through a dull sequence whereby Mr. Whipple (Dick Wilson) is snuck into the camp via Schnitzer's dog truck while Hogan and men stage their usual type of diversion, just so he can tell Hogan about the train taking Tiger away.

There was little real humor in this one. The head Gestapo man was not funny in the least. Carter's silly German official provided almost all of the laughs here in two scenes. And the big suspenseful story line about getting freeing Tiger despite the heavy guard was accomplished way too-easily by just two men overpowering two guards in one place, then the other two a moment later-almost silently, with no struggle, no alarms being sounded... just nothing much to it.

The whole thing about getting Tiger to be taken, as prisoner, to the camp only to go back onto the train where Hogan rescues her in a way he could have done in the first place shows weak writing. It just seems like we had to fill a few more pages of the script as nothing changed between the first time they stopped the train and the second time. Of course, Hogan asking permission from London and then arguing with his men about doing it on their own also seemed like a waste of time-it wasn't funny and didn't need to be in the story-except to fill the required time.

So I can only give it a 4.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed